Originally posted by Kazenji
YouTube video
Finally got around to watching this first trailer. Not sure what to think.
I fear that a large part of the charm of The Shining was the setting inside the big, spooky hotel. I mean, the hotel was seemingly mundane, but it of course became iconic. It doesn't seem like this will have much or any of that charm. So we'll see. Hope it's still interesting.
Some positive reviews... I'm intrigued. *shrug*
"Doctor Sleep is more interested in the lingering pain, and whether it's possible to come back from such trauma. In doing so, it steps out from the long shadow of the 1980 film, and becomes something great in its own right."Oct 31, 2019
Brandon Zachary
CBR
"Masters a creative tightrope walk, managing to play with "The Shining" in inventive ways while remaining a King-inspired ride of macabre events and tortured minds."Oct 31, 2019 | Rating: A-
Brian Orndorf
Blu-ray.com
"The occasional lapse in dialogue and unnecessary lull aside, this is a strong adaptation. It's scary and affecting and it brings one of King's best modern villains to life beautifully."Oct 31, 2019 | Rating: 3/5
Jonathan Hatfull
SciFiNow
Originally posted by Kazenji
Seems like Stephen King has accepted Kubrick's movie of The Shining over time, going by alot of the promotional stuff for this movie.
I noticed that in an article I read that quoted him several times. I was actually pretty surprised by that.
Must admit, i’m pretty interested in seeing this; they’ve done a good job w. their advertising. The early word of mouth is positive, the trailers are interesting w.out giving away too much, the cast seems solid.
Doctor Sleep was good and I enjoyed it, but the final act was very derivative and predictable. A lot of recreated shots and angles that are literally identical to the original.Worth seeing, especially if you’re a fan of the Shining.
7.5/10
Spoiler:, just to stick all those shots in there. It makes a kind of sense, in that moviegoers might really want that connection to the first movie, visually, while those that read the book probably didn’t care.
different from the book
I watched this, the Director's Cut.
I was really surprised how good it is! It's best when it's doing its own thing, though, and not recreating scenes from The Shining (there was a little too much of that). "Member The Shining??!"
But yeah, this is great. Better than IT Chapter 2 for sure. That film should have been more like this.
I pretty fully agree with RLM on their review for this...
didn't mind the film, was surprised it ran as long as it did and I liked the idea of the protagonist being much stronger than the antagonist right from the get go and pushing Danny to the secondary character didn't hurtt the film.
having said that, going back to the overlook hotel was dumb and the film dragged in some places for sure, also having Elliot from ET try and do a Jack Torrance was laughable
7/10