ROTS Mace Windu vs ROTJ Darth Vader

-All out fight to the death
-Fight takes place in the Geonosis arena
-Starting distance is 15m

Who wins?

Mace pretty easily.

Without vaapad / base Windu, Vader wins, given that pre-prime Vader is far more powerful than the Kar Vastor that is in turn more powerful than TCW Windu.

With vaapad and going all-out, Windu by his defeat of Sidious should win.

Split

Either way, yeah. Both are evenly matched in most aspects and all that are relevant anyways.

up

windu.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Split

Changing to Windu.

But Vader will give him hell first.

Windu curbstomps.

Vader, solidly.

Originally posted by ILS
Vader curbstomps.

Originally posted by ILS
Windu curbstomps.

Windu.