Saber's only: ROTS Obi-Wan Kenobi VS ROTJ Vader

Started by Geistalt2 pages

Obi-Wan:
TheNuisanceBird
Kurk
DarthAnt66
CuckedCurry (probably a sock)
JMANGO (also probably a sock)
deathslash
Geistalt

Vader:
The Ellimist
carthage
Haschwalth
Darth Thor

I also believe Vader would win.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Given Ahsoka stalemated Maul, id say shed have to at least be near ROTS Kenobi level.

Then we have to consider Vader was solidly above Ahsoka.

Harder to powerscale Legends without a common foe.

While I don't question Rebels Ahsoka's skill compared to Ezra and Kanan, her fight with Maul was mostly off screen. It's a matter of consistency with Ahsoka.

Ahsoka doesn't have the skill set Kenobi does to deal with Vader.

True. Galen in general is hard to scale with his numberous accolades and carrying feats.

Originally posted by Geistalt
Obi-Wan:
TheNuisanceBird
Kurk
DarthAnt66
CuckedCurry (probably a sock)
JMANGO (also probably a sock)
deathslash
Geistalt

Vader:
The Ellimist
carthage
Haschwalth
Darth Thor

Socks?

Either way as long as Ant's on my side I'm fine.

Yes, like the ones you stuff Christmas presents in.

Vader.

Obi-Wan Kenobi. Old Ben could stand his own against Vader. his younger version is definitely more powerful physically and the Force augumentation won't be necessary(that much)

vader can be assumed to be above Ahsoka holistically, but his performance on a nexus certainly doesn't imply a significant gap.

Or, you know, nexus don't actually give you huge jumps in power and saber ability.

They do if one does not replicate them without that Force aid.

ROTJ Vader was in his prime, unless we are using only canon content.

Originally posted by Geistalt
Geistalt (probably a cuck)

Interesting.

Obi-Wan:
TheNuisanceBird
Kurk
DarthAnt66
CuckedCurry
JMANGO
deathslash
Geistalt
Freedon Nadd

Vader:
The Ellimist
carthage
Haschwalth
Darth Thor
MythLord
FreshestSlice

Originally posted by Freedon Nadd
They do if one does not replicate them without that Force aid.

Both ROTS Kenobi and ROTJ Vader can fight perfectly fine without physical augmentation so it's not really an issue here.

Vader uses the Force to move his robotic body at 'Flash' speeds. On top of that, I was referring to Force nexuses.

Obi Wan would beat Vader in a straight up saber duel, add in Force TK though and its Vaders fight

Vader

Originally posted by Freedon Nadd
Vader uses the Force to move his robotic body at 'Flash' speeds. On top of that, I was referring to Force nexuses.

Doesn't every Force user use physical augmentation to move that fast?