Originally posted by One Big Mob
Do you still not understand what scale means? Do you not understand what examples are?
I've said multiple times it doesn't matter how much power Sentry put into it. I'm not trying to lowball him. I'm saying it's the exact same thing.Obviously I'm not trying to compare the power of the two, that's retarded. Even mocking this when you compare it more to a hydraulic press should have overruled this. But you are not thinking logically about it.
My example of the hydraulic is sound, because at least I'm presenting two cases with the same logical outcome aka two characters trying to counter a force going downward that they cannot stop at all.
Come on. You refuse to actually address half the things, and have an utter refusal to post proof or even explain your points.
I have all right to refuse answering to your poor attempts at moving the goalposts on irrelevancies. If you think that I will fall for this fallacious debating tactics only used by beginners, I will not.
You have, and will never convince anyone with that attitude.
The same way I will not convince religious fanatics that their god is a fictional character and that blowing up their asses will not give them a free entrance for some fictional realm. Understood. 👆
And you know that, because you pm'ed me a debate you had with Sharivan where you were actually refuting points, and posting proof. You have not devolved I think, you are simply clinging to nothing right now in the hopes that I stop.
I've actually told you that we can agree to disagree but hey, you are the one trying to antagonize me during 99% of the debate.
You are speaking about the scales but once more, you don't understand the difference in power between the heroes on Earth and a simple Celestial, so I guess that understanding the massive difference in power between Exitar and a single Celestial is too complicated. Right ?
Don't lecture me when you know for a fact you are not doing all you can to convince me, or even yourself.
99% of your posts are devoid at lecturing me...
Oh the irony ! 😆
Read yourself again please.
You can't teach me anything from how you're debating right now, because I've debated against people doing this tactic, lots. It's the reason why H1 is on ignore. It's the reason why I've considered the same here. And it's the reason why Galan and Phildo told me to put you on ignore. Because you will fall victim to shitty debating practices the second you are backed into a corner and can't defend your point.
Here we are back at your habit at using the psychological projection. I thought you was done with it. I'm reassured.
How did you explain a small scale test and then use a perfect example and try and toss it at me?
Let's see:
Helicarrier falling =/= Exitar pushing down.
A simple observation give you the answer but you are so full into your faulty analogy that you cannot backtrack it. Too bad for you.
The quantity of effort is reduced? So that's like using a lot less power than moving a planet, no? It was proportionally reduced, Sentry could not land the helicarrier on his own, and was having almost no luck until Ms Marvel and Wonder Man came in. You literally just showed why it was the same thing.
I will try again with keywords, because the previous sentences didn't hit you...
Finesse =/= Raw power.
Oh but maybe you don't what "finesse" and "raw power" means. Google it.
I assumed you knew those words. My bad.
No, it's not proportionally reduced because in the case of a "small test scale" all of the other settings have to be reduced accordingly. That means that Sentry power would have to be reduced too.
Anyway that's... ****ING IRRELEVANT.
They used a fraction of their power to stop a fraction of the weight, and needed help to stop it immediately. Simple, same thing even following your guidelines.
Read above.
However, to explain it without your guidelines and getting hung up on your refusal to even think they could be similar.
A weight was falling down. A man tried to stop it. He could not stop it in time. 2 people came and stopped it instantly. Everyone contributed.
Exitar wasn't falling down.
Did you had physics class or... ?
Yeah, a man tried to avoid the weight to suddenly stop and kill everyone on board. Different context than versus Exitar where Sentry actually produced an effort to stop the Force going down.
Now here's the problem. You can not think past the similarities or lack thereof in your case. Which is why I continue asking you about it. If Exitar never existed in canon.
Projecting.
Was everyone providing the power to stop the helicarrier, or did Ms Marvel/Wonder Man do all of the work? Sentry did nothing, and as soon as they put their hands on it, it stopped. It looks like they did all the work, does itCan you answer this? I'm really confused about it. Can you pretend you are actually trying to prove your case. Can you not shut your ears and lalalala me? I feel this is important, what happened there?
The Helicarrier feat is irrelevant, it's not surprising that you keep trying to divert the discussion on something that have a different context.
I am over simplifying it because that's exactly what you're saying.
Over-simplfying = changing an explanation to something that suits you = Strawmaning.
I've already shown examples of people doing nothing on their own against a weight that can have some effort on. It visibly looks like they did nothing, but a smart man knows better.
****ing irrelevant.
Sentry was far from using his full power because not only that was unneeded but dangerous for the crew.
You aren't even using logic here.
Projecting...
You're assuming Rogue did absolutely zero percent of the work
Her effort was negligible.
when that is simply how nothing works.
Yes it does.
Sentry has never fought Rogue with all the powers of the world.
Sentry has destroyed Molecule Man. Heck, I wonder why they don't bring Rogue with all the powers of the world in every fight because that seems to be the ultimate answer for you.
We do not know if he makes her look insignificant. We have nothing to show he is infinitely above her in strength, and this was far and away Sentry's best strength feat. You can't assume she did nothing at all, because you have no evidence. Evidence to the contrary actually.
Evidence shows she was useless because Exitar was sinking down and not slowed down.
[IMAGE]https://i.imgur.com/5ekrtXQ.jpg[/IMAGE]
Even if she did 5 percent of the work, she is still providing effort. She is still pushing.
Sure pal.
If Joe the Funny Guy and an ant are pushing my feet so I cannot land of the ground, the ant totally 50% of the job too.
Rogue was completely useless. Deal with it.
The fact that we have them saying half, and it being a joint effort proves she was had something to do with him being stopped. It is completely irrefutable. You are using examples that follow nothing except your self serving logic.
They said Half of the PLAN, not the effort.
I've already posted the definition of what PLAN means and you handwaved it because it crushed your beliefs.
Rogue was 50 % of the IDEA, about the effort she was an INSECT, completely useless.
The hydraulic press is only relevant because Sentry stopped Exitar. That is the bread and butter.
No, it is only relevant because if you put a metahuman and an human under the press and that the press is stopped, there is a big hint that's the metahuman whom stopped it and avoided the human to be crushed....
But hey, double standards.
But I've shown and used real world and a comic example to show this is not the case. Things can do nothing on their own on the surface, but in actuality will be providing a large percent. You have not even pretended this could exist, because the hydraulic press, and Sentry stopped Exitar. Do you see where the issue arises?
Already explained above.
But really, this is completely overruled by the summary saying it was a joint effort. Which means she was helping.
Yes she was trying to help.
There is no getting around that. All of what I said is only to back that up. You have not proven anything, you are ignoring everything, and are accusing me of being a fanboy? Hilarious.
Look at the scan that I've posted above, again, and tell me who is the one ignoring proofs on panel... Oh well that's you.
And what if thousands of people are pushing against the hydraulic press? Is each one nothing pushing? This is the whole concept here.
Yeah and Rogue powered by thousands of her kind was completely useless, as shown on panel.
Additional force helps. That's what happens in real life, that's what happens in comics.
It helps when it's not completely NEGLIGIBLE LIKE HERE.
That's what happened against Exitar.
It doesn't.
It was a joint effort as they say.
They were two to push and only Sentry had a relevant strength but hey... Hello to your double standards again. 🙂
Come on man. I ****ing called it. How can you accuse me of not reading anything when you pull this shit?
It is just plain obvious.
The fact that you can't answer it speaks volumes.
It speaks volumes about your inability to grasp the context and ask pertinent questions.