Originally posted by JMANGO
Not forgetting that the guy just compared him to esb luke... the same person who's lightsaber skill is non existent at this point, and while in calm state of mind, can't even TK an x-wing.
Originally posted by deathslash
naw, he did just as well against Vader as ESB Luke did. Difference being that Vader was actually fighting to kill him.
Roan fought a Vader a few months after RotS. He was a relative feeb at that point, barely used to his new self at all. Roan is likely an above average Jedi Master, but that's about it.
Originally posted by FreshestSlicehmm maybe not always but aurra only had very limited training so it is unlikely that she would have surpassed her master. logically they at least should be in the same general area if not the dark woman being superior. if we don't know for sure then that is the safest bet.
Training someone does not make you remotely comparable to them, or them comparable to you.
Originally posted by FreshestSlicewell the emperors wrath clearly has very high raw power/potential relative to most of his time so it is not unbelievable for him to surpass his master even when his training was limited because raw power has a v.strong effect on power growth. so that would be an exception and not comparable, imo. aurra's training was also far more limited than the wrath's as it stopped when she was only 9 years old before she even mastered the basics, whereas the wrath had an 'accelerated training regime' in his time at the sith academy and constantly practiced via the intense warfare of those times.
Using SWTOR as an example, as it's in this thread, Baras limited the Wrath's training because he thought that would lead to him dying, which it did. Didn't stop him from being defeated. Your logic doesn't make any sense.
and so without any reason to believe that aurra is a high potential character who can grow despite lack of technical knowledge or knowledge on how to properly control her power, i would say it is logical to say that the dark woman is superior.