JLA vs Avengers (with a twist)

Thor
Captain America
Black Widow
Bruce Banner
Hawkeye

vs

Superman
Aquaman
Wonder Woman
Batman (Affleck)
Flash

Inspired by the Iron Man vs Cap thread.

They are all stripped of their powers. No super strength/durability/speed/etc.

They are allowed their current skills and the physical stats equal to a person of their size/weight/physique (use actor stats). They also fight in UFC attire, thus no gear.

Each side believes that the other side are just illusions in a realistic game and will fight to kill with zero hesitation the way a gamer would kill video game enemies.

Team battle inside the Thunderdome (no weapons tho). 2 team enters. 1 team leaves.

Interesting match. Avengers have more trained fighters, but the JL have the overall physicality/size edge.

I kind of imagine a fight between de-powered Banner and de-powered Flash going like this though:

YouTube video

Just to clarify, is Steve stripped of his powers but still retains his ripped physical stature or does he go back to his 90 lbs weak self?

Originally posted by FrothByte
Just to clarify, is Steve stripped of his powers but still retains his ripped physical stature or does he go back to his 90 lbs weak self?

Ripped Steve.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Ripped Steve.

Ah, well then, MCU teams wins decisively. Flash and Banner will be pretty useless in this fight. That means the MCU teams is left with 4 highly trained, highly skilled fighters in peak physical condition with a buttload of experience and each one has feats of easily defeating an opponent (or multiple opponents) who are roughly in their physical stat range.

The DCEU team is left with 4 fighters in peak physical condition, one of which is completely untrained and has minimal experience, one is arguably trained but has minimal feats (Aquaman), and 2 highly-skilled/trained fighters. Of them all, only Batman has feats where he easily defeats opponents who are within his physical stat range (Diana usually struggles with opponents who are similar to her physicality).

The DCEU team has a slight size advantage but the MCU team has too big an advantage in skill and experience. Plus they're more used to working together. There's also the fact that MCU team are way more willing to kill.

Banner showed some skills in Incredible Hulk though

So this is basically the characters with no power vs. each other? Marvel stomps.

Banner and Flash are autolosses. Useless.Superman will now ironically lose to anybody he faces.

Batman and WonderWoman are the only chances here. If they can take out Clint and Widow while Thor and Cap beat up Clark and Arthur then there is a chance Batman can find a way to win.not likely though.

Marvel 8/10. 4 trained fighters with years of experience, fought multiple wars and have each killed countless opponents

Vs. 2 of the same thing basically and two ripped guys 1 who is decent and 1 who has been in 3 fight s their entire life.

This is Marvel's fight to lose. Should have traded Supes and Arthur for a powerless Faora and Zod or somebody from suicide squad. That would been a 50/50 fight

Though I personally believe Batfleck is probably the most dangerous individual in this thread he can't tip the odds in his team's favor. Flash is pretty much useless, Superman, though big and strong, is just a brawler, and Diana, while skilled, would find herself being likely the physically weakest person here (Gal Gadot is very skinny and has a very slight build). Aquaman might be skilled, but I doubt his skills eclipse those of Thor, Cap, Hawkeye, or Black Widow.

Marvel takes a very hefty majority.

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Ripped Steve.

Odinson and Rumanoff are enough to finish the JL.