Asajj Ventress vs. Kit Fisto

Started by xPRIMEx2 pages

Asajj Ventress vs. Kit Fisto

Fight to the death. Who wins?

Fisto in his prime

Ventress solidly

Fisto's allegedly one of the top twenty Jedi in the Order's history (in Canon).

Then Ventress would be one of the top 15

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Fisto's allegedly one of the top twenty Jedi in the Order's history (in Canon).

Sauce?

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-OkEExF15pgw/WadorO-Y3TI/AAAAAAAAEg4/F8NCfpHdrCAjhmY5PL9kGzxb6rA9Zw1eQCHMYCw/s1600/RCO014_w.jpg

* "Top twenty to thirty," my bad.

It's not an objective source, but comes from an in-universe Jedi SW debater, so I value her opinion.

Plus author intent and all that yada.

-

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-OkEExF15pgw/WadorO-Y3TI/AAAAAAAAEg4/F8NCfpHdrCAjhmY5PL9kGzxb6rA9Zw1eQCHMYCw/s1600/RCO014_w.jpg

* "Top twenty to thirty," my bad.

It's not an objective source, but comes from an in-universe Jedi SW debater, so I value her opinion.

Plus author intent and all that yada.

In the same issue, Mace also stated that Kit's skills with a lightsaber were "unrivaled":
https://i.imgur.com/2TgMv7L.jpg

I mean in legends you can argue Shii-Cho < Makashi, but canon doesn't seem to value the technicalities of combat very much.

Well Ahsokas opinion as stated to Luminara, was that no single Jedi could defeat Ventress.

Which is false.

didnt ventress defeat plenty jedi masters. master llumaniti right?

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Which is false.

Which is his point.

Stupid point. 👆

Just because Tano thinks Ventress is a Sith doesn't mean Purple-girl is retarded also, lol.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-OkEExF15pgw/WadorO-Y3TI/AAAAAAAAEg4/F8NCfpHdrCAjhmY5PL9kGzxb6rA9Zw1eQCHMYCw/s1600/RCO014_w.jpg

* "Top twenty to thirty," my bad.

It's not an objective source, but comes from an in-universe Jedi SW debater, so I value her opinion.

Plus author intent and all that yada.

when that Jedi claimed fisto was top 20/30 Ventress probably hadn’t even joined the separatist yet, or at best was only at the beginning of her career as a dark Jedi.

Fisto wins more times than not.

People have this weird thinking that when X defeats Y without some ridiculous circumstances it's suddenly X >>>> Y. Fights are random, one random move, one random placement means someone inferior can defeat his superior. You have Maul defeating Qui-Gon in 95% of situations, Maul being obviously superior by every possible account, but Qui-Gon can win these 5 out of 100 fights.

This is how I see Fisto vs. Ventress. Besides their fight, which was by the way also random, Fisto is superior in accolades, historic placement, feats, Force power, speed.

Originally posted by JKBart
Maul wins more times than not.

People have this weird thinking that when X defeats Y without some ridiculous circumstances it's suddenly X >>>> Y. Fights are random, one random move, one random placement means someone inferior can defeat his superior. You have Maul defeating Qui-Gon in 95% of situations, Maul being obviously superior by every possible account, but Qui-Gon can win these 5 out of 100 fights.

This is how I see Maul vs. Sidious. Besides their fight, which was by the way also random, Maul is superior in accolades, historic placement, feats, Force power, speed.

^ Nice but I thought you were going with Maul vs Kenobi/Dooku in that edit.

@Total Warrior: When Ventress joined the Separatists has no bearing on the quote's impressiveness.