Well if you want to go off that sh1tty "best red lightsaber wielders" book who am I to argue.
CAR
carthagePLEASE PROTECT ME STONES
Dooku and it’s a stomp
TW
Total WarriorDark Councilor
Still Dooku
GEI
GeistaltSilenceThatSpeaksVolumes
Dooku, with moderate difficulty.
DT
Darth ThorSenior Member
If we compare against Kenobi, then Dooku stomps.
But if we compare against Savage, then Maul is back in the game.
Think Mauls chances are best with his Saber Staff, given Dookus more of a pure fencer, and struggles against fast, unorthodox and unpredictable movements - see Dooku vs Vos.
DAR
DarthAnt66DarthAnt66
Gillard has heavily indicated Dooku >> Maul and Filoni likely has Dooku > Maul too.
FN
Freedon NaddSenior Member
This would be like Dooku vs Anakin, only that Maul is better at swordplaying.
SHE
SheevBeyond Darkness
Dooku stomps.
DT
Darth ThorSenior Member
Originally posted by DarthAnt66 Gillard has heavily indicated Dooku >> Maul and Filoni likely has Dooku > Maul too.
Didnt Gillard rate them both as an 8?
Filoni would rate dog shit above Maul. But hes never made that direct comparison.
DAR
DarthAnt66DarthAnt66
Yeah but he told me in an email that there's a big gap between them.
He didn't say which way it leaned but presumably toward Dooku.
DT
Darth ThorSenior Member
^ Didnt he say there “Can” be a big gap between them?
Either way, nothing concrete from either Filoni or Gillard. Except that TPM Maul was already an 8 at that time.
SHE
SheevBeyond Darkness
Wasnt it stated somewhere that Maul only managed a stalemate against Grievous?
ROC
Rockydonovangfreedom fighter
Originally posted by Sheev Wasnt it stated somewhere that Maul only managed a stalemate against Grievous?
Wasn't stated anywhere. And they didn't really stalemate, the fight was inconclusive.
ILS
ILSRestricted
Interesting thread. I wonder if we'll hear any actually good arguments for Dookie.
GAL
Galan007|Quantum Observer|
Originally posted by Rockydonovang Wasn't stated anywhere. And they didn't really stalemate, the fight was inconclusive.
He *might* be talking about this, but I'm not sure:
SHE
SheevBeyond Darkness
Thats it. 😎
LS
Lord StarkLord of Winterfell
Originally posted by DarthAnt66 Yeah but he told me in an email that there's a big gap between them.
He didn't say which way it leaned but presumably toward Dooku.
Lol really? What did he say?
Btw Dooku stomps.
DAR
DarthAnt66DarthAnt66
Dooku & Maul are 8, but there is a huge difference inside the numbers themselves, it's not about how well they fight, it's about how well they learned.
