Who is more heroic; Thor or Superman

Started by Josh_Alexander3 pages
Originally posted by WolvesofBabylon
Well according to you Thor failed to stop Thanos so he basically is responsible for killing half the Universe.

😂

He aimed wrongly so... yeah.

Originally posted by WolvesofBabylon
Well according to you Thor failed to stop Thanos so he basically is responsible for killing half the Universe.
No. Trying to stop a car from running over a kid and failing doesn't make you an accomplice to murder. People need to stop with this nonsense. A lot of characters ****ed up in IW, but no one besides Thanos is really to blame.

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
No. Trying to stop a car from running over a kid and failing doesn't make you an accomplice to murder. People need to stop with this nonsense. A lot of characters ****ed up in IW, but no one besides Thanos is really to blame.

Thor and Starlord ****ed up the most.

But who knows, in the end Strange made it perfectly clear there was only 1 way to defeating Thanos so...Perhaps it wouldn't have mattered in the end.

Superman took steps in the right direction during Justice League, but Thor is still more heroic at this point.

True, he didn't try and kill nearly as many people in Justice League, that was a big step for him.

You could tell they were trying to make him more traditional in JL. Just like they turned Thor into a comedian in Ragnarok

thor is clearly more heroic than Supes..

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Heroic as in saving lives?
All aspects of heroism.

Superman and Cap are the ideals when it comes to heroic icons and always have been. Thor is a heroic and great hero too, but he's held back by his arrogance and levity concerning the taking of lives.

DCEU Superman has never been the ideal when it comes to heroic.

when you hold a gun and aim, i believe it should and most times been aimed for the HEAD not the chest..wellll thor with his what..? thousandss of years of experience was so dumb as to aiming a weapon (so powerful it could kill thanos) to the chest. That Is Just So Unheroic. He Let Marvel Down, He Let Jl Down, Damn He Let His Mentor And Model Superman Down

😖ad:

You are actually 100% wrong, both the military and law enforcement train people to aim for center mass and not the head.

Originally posted by Arachnid1
Superman and Cap are the ideals when it comes to heroic icons and always have been. Thor is a heroic and great hero too, but he's held back by his arrogance and levity concerning the taking of lives.
Once again you show your bias. You are such a Superman fanboy. Thor is extremely heroic and doesn’t stop so don’t confuse the topic you disillusioned fanboy.

Originally posted by The Spectre+
when you hold a gun and aim, i believe it should and most times been aimed for the HEAD not the chest..wellll thor with his what..? thousandss of years of experience was so dumb as to aiming a weapon (so powerful it could kill thanos) to the chest. That Is Just So Unheroic. He Let Marvel Down, He Let Jl Down, Damn He Let His Mentor And Model Superman Down

😖ad:

You have OBVIOUSLY never been in the military or some kind of police force. When you are trained you are to aim CENTER MASS. That is the training. If you're a cop and you shoot someone in the face when you could have taken them down with a shot to the gut you are going to get absolutely destroyed by your unit and ESPECIALLY the media. Thor also thought that would Kill Thanos, he underestimated Thanos' resilience.

Anyway, Superman has been emo-man for his first 2.5 movies. Thor has been a hero Since Thor 1 and gotten better character development and payoffs.

Edit:

Originally posted by Silent Master
You are actually 100% wrong, both the military and law enforcement train people to aim for center mass and not the head.
Beat me to it. 👆

Superman gets you have to break a few eggs to make an Omelette. Thor should have gone for the head.

Originally posted by Putinbot1
Superman gets you have to break a few eggs to make an Omelette. Thor should have gone for the head.
Hmm that's right. Stuperman's philosophy is to attack DD with a kryponite spear making it possible for the cave troll to kill him in the process instead of handing off the spear to WW. At least Thor thought his attack would kill Thanos WITHOUT getting him killed in the process. Superman's plan was just plain stupid.

Thor.

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
Hmm that's right. Stuperman's philosophy is to attack DD with a kryponite spear making it possible for the cave troll to kill him in the process instead of handing off the spear to WW. At least Thor thought his attack would kill Thanos WITHOUT getting him killed in the process. Superman's plan was just plain stupid.

Superman just loves killing so much he'll even kill himself.

Thor tried to kill Cap.

He's out.

Originally posted by Juk3n
Thor tried to kill Cap.

He's out.

Superman tried to kill the entire Justice League. And killed (succesfully) the last few members of his race. The S stands for “genocide”.

😱