Non-canon.
I can even post the writer of the story whom said that's non-canon.
Originally posted by Baziemarc123
LOL I honestly never knew it was a dream and i missed that. glad you posted it
You are welcome.
Originally posted by Stoic
Galan was it canon or not? If not, it kind of changes things a bit.
Galan uses a scan from Rebirth that shows that Mxy is aware of all of his incarnations in medium.
It doesn't make the story canon for all that.
Originally posted by cdtm
The caption just says what Alan Moore said, that all comic stories are imaginary stories.That being admitted as a "gag" doesn't make it non canon. It just means the writers thought it was funny.
No.
You are actually misunderstanding it.
The writer of the story confirmed it didn't happen. Twice.
https://s15.postimg.cc/ivj422ddn/2017-03-10.png
https://s15.postimg.cc/e9mztq7a3/4789038-7011790474-47713.jpg
We cannot debate about it. That settle that.
Originally posted by cdtm
The caption just says what Alan Moore said, that all comic stories are imaginary stories.That being admitted as a "gag" doesn't make it non canon. It just means the writers thought it was funny.
Originally posted by Baziemarc123
yes which wasn't meant to be taken seriously unless we wanna use Deadpool insane gag moments including of him beating the whole marvel
cdtm, Bazie has a point here. This new info kind of makes it difficult to judge clearly from my perspective. Anyway, I've always had a hard time understanding how one omnipotent defeats another one unless it is seen in a comic. Maybe it's just me though.
Originally posted by Baziemarc123
I always have a point. it's just you dudes are always too blinded by your ignorance
They do that all the time.
They wilfully ignore proofs when they are posted and make personal attacks when people ask them to prove their claims.
Originally posted by Stoic
cdtm, Bazie has a point here. This new info kind of makes it difficult to judge clearly from my perspective. Anyway, I've always had a hard time understanding how one omnipotent defeats another one unless it is seen in a comic. Maybe it's just me though.
I never understood that, either.
Should be a stalemate, or an inability to really fight/interact, like a higher level Wolverine vs Lady Deathstrike from Xmen 2.
I love the pick and choose what serves my purpose to defend my stance cause.
The same people that says it’s not canon because the writer says so, are the same people that will use a writers note to prove their point if it serves them.
News flash, Mxy has alr day said it himself, everything you see of him is himself. He has no alternate or non canon selfs. Hell, iin one comic, we see Mxy being pissed off, and he’s casually destroying everything.
He’s even claiming that’s hes pissed off at everything, all the retcon, all the different timelines, everything.
[QUOTE=16623826]Originally posted by Baziemarc123
yes which wasn't meant to be taken seriously unless we wanna use Deadpool insane gag moments including of him beating the whole marvel [/QUOTE
Because Mxy is a legitimately op reality warper, who utilized absurd powers such as toon force and the ability to retcon outside of World's Funnest. Also, Joker displaying feats that are not that hax compared to what Mxy displayed in World's Funnest, canon or not, obviously further supports the assessment that Mxy is capable of treating 3d dimensional space as joke and causing dimensional haywire that affected even his dimension. Deadpool is not a reality warper and therefore his 4th wall breaking showings are illogical to use in battlezone, whereas Mxy's are not.
Originally posted by SquallX
I love the pick and choose what serves my purpose to defend my stance cause.The same people that says it’s not canon because the writer says so, are the same people that will use a writers note to prove their point if it serves them.
News flash, Mxy has alr day said it himself, everything you see of him is himself. He has no alternate or non canon selfs. Hell, iin one comic, we see Mxy being pissed off, and he’s casually destroying everything.
He’s even claiming that’s hes pissed off at everything, all the retcon, all the different timelines, everything.
His self-awareness doesn't make the story canon.
Originally posted by StoicThe feats I mentioned for Emperor Joker are all canon, yes.
Galan was it canon or not? If not, it kind of changes things a bit.
As for Mxy: ALL of his appearances(across ALL forms of media) are canon to him:
_________________________________________________
The only people who still try to contest this are butthurt trolls. Pay them no mind. 😉
Originally posted by Galan007
The feats I mentioned for Emperor Joker are all canon, yes.As for Mxy: ALL of his appearances(across ALL forms of media) are canon to him:
_________________________________________________
The only people who still try to contest this are butthurt trolls. Pay them no mind. 😉
It doesn't change the fact that WF Mxy never happened.
Hence it is not canon, whatever Mxy is self-aware or not.
There is no correlation with the canonicity of an event. 😉
