Originally posted by Philosophía
The "H" he carves on their chest probably doesn't help either.Wasn't carver, like, the last guy to send you his post? As in, everybody had already pulled out by then, stating it in the thread itself?
Yes, both he and LoB posted a bit late.
He probably just didn't see that Leo dropped out though honestly.
PR is now judging by the way.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Dambo should've made it clear I had my wish as he swore on his firstborn Carver9 he would do 👆
Even if he had DS. You still didnt show luminal speed (confirmed for me from the judge that didnt allow your wish and my downfal to LOB with superluminal). So either I soul controlled you to depower SBP for the win b4 he pushes planet into the sun or just make the sun go out, or your wish took place after the Planet is in the sun.
Given that the version of Fate I'd used was actually shown immune to planetary reality warping in the story most of his scans came from your wish wasnt winning it for you anyway.
Of course he didnt show that, neither did I show Todd resisting Chroma's reality warping (though it was IIRC no where near planetary level).
Originally posted by NemeBro
Also, if anyone has any critique regarding my ruling or just wants to say I'm a retard, I welcome it. This was my first battlezone/tourney I've ever judged and I wasn't sure how to approach it in some ways. I asked Dambo and leonidas some general questions but if someone else thinks I'm a stupid idiot who did it wrong let me know. 👆
You explained and justified your position. Thats really all anyone can ask. Everyone sees things differently, it'd be a very boring world if we didnt. No one should have to justify their view beyond what you did. Others seeing it differently is just their own emotional position on things with their knowedge slant colouring position. I for example know that I'ds version of Fate is immune to reality manip so would discount the wish against him others who dont wouldnt
Originally posted by beatboks
Even if he had DS. You still didnt show luminal speed (confirmed for me from the judge that didnt allow your wish and my downfal to LOB with superluminal). So either I soul controlled you to depower SBP for the win b4 he pushes planet into the sun or just make the sun go out, or your wish took place after the Planet is in the sun.Given that the version of Fate I'd used was actually shown immune to planetary reality warping in the story most of his scans came from your wish wasnt winning it for you anyway.
Of course he didnt show that, neither did I show Todd resisting Chroma's reality warping (though it was IIRC no where near planetary level).
My point was, I specifically asked Dambo to tell judges, after we agreed I could wish.
He specifically said he would.
If I lose because of anything else, sure, fine. But not because a judge wasn't told by the host specific rulings, agreed?
Had he said no, then there was still time for me to rewrite my strat (I was early enough to be able to do so). But he said yes, so I left it as is.
Originally posted by NemeBro
And Saint, if Damborgson did rule before you started that you have access to wishes without the wishing well I apologize. I looked through the thread to get a look at any various rulings, specifically for you actually because I remember there being some discussion between you and carver on the WBH version you're using, and I honestly didn't see it.
From this post, it looked like Nemebro didn't think I had access lol.....
So I know your game plan involved making wishes without the use of the wishing machine. I read your post. I just wasn't convinced that Hulk actually depowered anyone in your scans without the use of it, and my impression was that your post was intended to convince me of that strategy being a viable one.
Did Dambo ever say to me "So in this tourney go in taking Hulk being able to grant himself wishes without the machine as a given,"? No, as far as I recall that never happened.
Originally posted by NemeBro
So I know your game plan involved making wishes without the use of the wishing machine. I read your post. I just wasn't convinced that Hulk actually depowered anyone in your scans without the use of it, and my impression was that your post was intended to convince me of that strategy being a viable one.
There you go Saint.
Obsidian was made to look beastly in the post, and he had a nice strategy that I feel would be capable of winning if not for Prime trying to push the planet in to the sun.
AAARGGGHHH
Even though I couldn't find the scan of Todd warping space I should have still shadow travelled to she dark side of the moon at the onset of battle as I had originally planned. to be safely away from the actual battle myself while my shadow selves did their thing.
that'll teach me