Star Forge Valkorion vs. RotS Sidious

Started by The Ellimist2 pages

Star Forge Valkorion vs. RotS Sidious

who wins

Sidious,
Lightsaber skills win it all...

I wonder how much Valkorion would even get out of the Star Forge.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I wonder how much Valkorion would even get out of the Star Forge.

Probably not a lot, he doesn't need it here though.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I wonder how much Valkorion would even get out of the Star Forge.

From Malak's commentary to Revan, it seems like Malak didn't completely unlock its power.

Anyway I'm not sure who wins.

-

Perhaps Revan should've tried to unlock it and use it against Vitiate?

I’d need to brush up on my Star Forge lore. At first glance, it seems pretty discouraging for Valk here: the Star Forge didn’t sufficiently empower Malak to defeat Revan, so I’m not sure it would enable Valk to bridge the chasm between him and the Emperor.

How many limbs does Sheev have and are there any ysalamiri around him?

Well, unamped Malak is pretty shit, so this all depends on how you view the gap between a fodder and an Exar Kun+ in comparison to the one between Failkorion and Sheev. I'd personally say the former is smaller.

Originally posted by Azronger
Well, unamped Malak is pretty shit

lmao

why the **** is my name Jaggarath

Raz is trolling you, I imagine

valk oneshots Arcann/Vaylin/Outlander/etc.

palp = yoda who struggles against dooku

vader thought karness murr would help him beat palpatine, meanwhile karness murr is trash compared to valk

valk is literally a threat to entire armies and galactic fleets, sidious and yoda meanwhile would struggle against ~100 well trained soldiers as Yoda has

valk wins lol

Originally posted by Valkorion
valk oneshots Arcann/Vaylin/Outlander/etc.

Citation needed on oneshotting Vaylin/Outlander in a real fight.

palp = yoda who struggles against dooku

Yet Dooku is terrified of Sidious while thinking he can take AotC Yoda. He then does arguably worse against Yoda in Dark Rendevous despite having grown stronger *and* being on a powerful dark side nexus. Clearly Yoda wasn't fighting all-out, or otherwise hadn't gotten back up to form as he had by RotS.

Not that this matters because 1) Yoda never tries to attack Dooku with the Force but instead engages him in lightsaber combat and 2) you haven't established how Valkorion would do against Dooku.

vader thought karness murr would help him beat palpatine, meanwhile karness murr is trash compared to valk

Just as strong of a line of scaling can be used to establish that Karness Murr is trash compared to Sidious. There's also no reason to think that Vader, even if he were correct about Karness's power, thought this involved literally tag-teaming Palpatine in a 2-1 fight.

valk is literally a threat to entire armies and galactic fleets, sidious and yoda meanwhile would struggle against ~100 well trained soldiers as Yoda has

Nice medium hacking. Valk < Smuggler amirite?

Mace Windu as of OCW is soloing entire droid armies.

--------

You can line Palpatine and Valkorion up and Sidious comes out on top in almost every category.

You must be terribly bored if you're debating a sock.

Half of kmc is a sock lmao

At least most are known.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Citation needed on oneshotting Vaylin/Outlander in a real fight.

my bad he does it as a weakened spirit in outlander's head where the outlander is said to be even more powerful than normal lmao

Yet Dooku is terrified of Sidious

well yeah he's still weaker than yoda/sidious


while thinking he can take AotC Yoda.

we're talking about how they actually fight not how dooku expects it to go

He then does arguably worse against Yoda in Dark Rendevous

no he doesn't...?

despite having grown stronger *and* being on a powerful dark side nexus. Clearly Yoda wasn't fighting all-out, or otherwise hadn't gotten back up to form as he had by RotS.

Not that this matters because 1) Yoda never tries to attack Dooku with the Force but instead engages him in lightsaber combat and

so yoda let dooku escape and started a galactic war because he wanted to measure lightsabers rather than just ragdoll him? sureeee

2) you haven't established how Valkorion would do against Dooku.

dooku worshipped darth anddedu lol

Just as strong of a line of scaling can be used to establish that Karness Murr is trash compared to Sidious.

no it can't, we just know Sidious > each ancient sith, not that they're trash

There's also no reason to think that Vader, even if he were correct about Karness's power, thought this involved literally tag-teaming Palpatine in a 2-1 fight.

so what they're going to hire a sniper or something?

Nice medium hacking. Valk < Smuggler amirite?

Mace Windu as of OCW is soloing entire droid armies.

the republic and sith didn't think their entire fleets could stop vitiate

You can line Palpatine and Valkorion up and Sidious comes out on top in almost every category.

prove

So...who are you?

(PM me if you want)