MVP: Superman or Hal???

Only applicable showings are during and AFTER rebirth. Who wins the MVP on best WON combat showings? Opponents they've koed withiut any context or outside amp. Who is the Herald of DC? The class of opponent matters as well.

Go!!!

Superman did straight overpower a serious Hal in a beam struggle /shrug

Take that as you will.

There's also the whole 'Lanterns are weak against bricks' thing, and Superman fights a lot of bricks.

Anyway, Orion and Zod will be brought up a lot, I expect.

Read the thread please. It's not a Supes vs Hal in a fight thread.

Hal.

Originally posted by carver9
Read the thread please. It's not a Supes vs Hal in a fight thread.

Read my post please.

You wanted how they perform against similar opponents.

Well Lanterns are weak against bricks', as per you.

Superman fights bricks really often. Like Zod and Orion.

So he does better. No one says 'Superman is weak against bricks' , lol.

Which implies he doesn't lose against them

I like Hal more. I will vote Hal

Hal.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Read my post please.

You wanted how they perform against similar opponents.

Well Lanterns are weak against bricks', as per you.

Superman fights bricks really often. Like Zod and Orion.

So he does better. No one says 'Superman is weak against bricks' , lol.

Which implies he doesn't lose against them

I didn't make this thread based off of my opinion. I'm sure you're at the age to have your own opinion, even if I am your role model. Please base your decision off of how you feel, not off of what I think. Everyone else is doing it.

Superman.

I don't see how this isn't Hal. He has the superior showings, during rebirth.

He doesn't.

Superman is explcitly superior, including in Hal's own book. But lets see just how desperate people are to lie about this fact.

Not to mention Superman flat out overpowered Parallax trying to overtake him. Not even Jordan has ever pulled a stunt like that.