Rank these Star Wars works in quality

Started by The Ellimist1 pages

Rank these Star Wars works in quality

RotJ
RotS
RotS novelization
TOR
KOTET
Dynasty of Evil
Crystal Star
Revan novel
KotOR
KotOR II
ESB
LotF
FotJ
NJO
TLJ
TFA
Battlefront II (original)
Battlefront II (remake)
Thrawn Trilogy
Bloodlines

ROTS Novel is definitely at the top for me.

TLJ is definitely at the bottom.

ESB
RotS novelization
RotJ
Battlefront II ( original )
Thrawn Trilogy
RotS
KOTOR I
KOTOR II
Dynasty of Evil
LotF
FotJ
Revan
KOTET
Battlefront II ( remake )
Crystal Star
Bloodlines
TFA
TLJ

Needs Specification

TOR ( what does this encompass? )
NJO ( what does this encompass? )

I would assume the video game and the series respectively.

Re: Rank these Star Wars works in quality

RotJ / RotS / ESB

KotOR
RotS novelization
Thrawn Trilogy

Battlefront II (original)
KotOR II
NJO
TOR
LotF

FotJ
TFA
Battlefront II (remake)

Dynasty of Evil

Revan novel

KOTET
Crystal Star
Bloodlines

TLJ

1. ESB / RotJ / RotS
2. Kotor II
3. NJO series / RotS novelization / KotOR I
4. Thrawn Trilogy
----
5. TOR / LotF
6. FotJ
---
7. Revan novel / TFA / Bloodlines / Dynasty of Evil
8. KotET
---
9. Crystal Star / TLJ

Didn't play BF.

Anyone who doesn't put the original KOTOR at the top needs to atone for this sin.

What sin, anyone with a modicum of taste knows KotOR II was better anyway.

Spoiler:
fight me child

Galan should ban you just for that ❌

Originally posted by RealistRacism
Galan should ban you just for that ❌

LOL

Originally posted by RealistRacism
Anyone who doesn't put the original KOTOR at the top needs to atone for this sin.

"Forgive me master"
-Anakin Skywalker

OT-Mostly bias especially if you look at my avatar, name and sig but LOTF is definitely at the top. Closely followed by ROTS Novel tbh. Mostly nostalgia but the movie is my favourite SW film [Been so since I was a kid] and the novel makes it 100 times better.

ROTS Novel is the GOAT material of the literature, tbh.

Originally posted by Beelzebub
ESB
RotS novelization

Great top 2.

If we combine films with their respective novels then I think the ROTS film + novelisation together would probably be my top pick for any Star Wars Episode.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Great top 2.

If we combine films with their respective novels then I think the ROTS film + novelisation together would probably be my top pick for any Star Wars Episode.

That's a definite from me. The ROTS movie has the best fights (choreography wise) and music in Star Wars.

Plus it has Ewan McGregor onscreen.

Agreed. The novel just adds so much needed context.

Originally posted by Beelzebub
Agreed. The novel just adds so much needed context.

Matthew Stover's genius can probably make TFA and TLJ slightly better.

RotS Novel
ESB
RotJ
RotS
KotOR 2
KotOR
TOR (main storyline)
FotJ
NJO
Revan
LotF
DoE
KOTET
TFA
TLJ

Haven't watched/read/played the others