Originally posted by WolvesofBabylonTerrible argument tbh. Plus if it was so forgettable we would not have it in thriving in our pop culture to this day.
Most of HP is forgettable honestly.
It is deeper, better acting, have more than a basic and kid like view of our antagonists, and far better special effects with an adult like ending not Ewoks roasting marshmallows lovin life.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Terrible argument tbh. Plus if it was so forgettable we would not have it in thriving in our pop culture to this day.It is deeper, better acting, have more than a basic and kid like view of our antagonists, and far better special effects with an adult like ending not Ewoks roasting marshmallows lovin life.
Star Wars, LOTR, MCU.. All better Universes compared to Potter. As for being Deeper, you are comparing 8 films with roughly 20 hours of film time to Star Wars 6 hours so I would hope you are able to carve out a little more detail.
And yet with triple the amount of run time. Still pretty forgettable. I dont even remember the ending of Harry Potter. I couldnt tell you how Voldemort dies off the top of my head.
Originally posted by WolvesofBabylonSo now it is unfair is it? Awwww, you know characters never really get too deep.
Star Wars, LOTR, MCU.. All better Universes compared to Potter. As for being Deeper, you are comparing 8 films with roughly 20 hours of film time to Star Wars 6 hours so I would hope you are able to carve out a little more detail.And yet with triple the amount of run time. Still pretty forgettable. I dont even remember the ending of Harry Potter. I couldnt tell you how Voldemort dies off the top of my head.
MCU is the best but this has always been the greatest lore of any property.
Iyo not mine. Star Wars is very superficial but hey if that is what you love it can work. You are not a Wizarding World fan but Star Wars has been altered so much it is amusing to watch the hardcore fans openly sob over Lucas alterations with the Noooooooooooo. I loved that it hurt the fanboys of an overrated trilogy that is just nostalgic based. Poorly acted, thin characters, basic plot, happy ending nonsense. It is nowhere near the quality of Harry Potter. Just try not to be ruled by your nostalgic feelings and try to be a little objective.
Originally posted by Impediment
The OT stands the test of time. Proof of what one man and his vision can accomplish.HP is over-marketed, overhyped, and mostly forgettable.
Yeah. I have seen all the movies (on TV, really glad I didn't give them any money) and barring a few scenes...I can't recall hardly anything about them.
They were fun but def made for kids stuff...which I wouldn't have liked even when I was a kid.
Originally posted by FlyattractorStar Wars is definitely more for kids than the later Potter films. Lucas even says for 12 year olds. You can continue to be delusional but I will rub your nose in the facts.
[b]Yeah. I have seen all the movies (on TV, really glad I didn't give them any money) and barring a few scenes...I can't recall hardly anything about them.
They were fun but def made for kids stuff...which I wouldn't have liked even when I was a kid. [/B]
Kiddy stuff.
😂
Originally posted by FlyattractorSo since Ewoks died they still get a pg rating. Bambis mom died you idiot. What was its rating? 😉
[b]And shortly after that scene we saw the ewoks going into battle with the Empire where they suffered huge causalities.And they didn't have a "Get out of Death Spell" Like Harry did in his movies.
So there is that.
[/B]
Pg13>Pg.
Moron.
Return of the Jedi
PG 1983 ‧ Fantasy/Science Fiction ‧ 2h 16m
Originally posted by FlyattractorIt was a pg film. Lucas agreed it is for 12 year olds. Your sunk, loser. Kiddy stuff you love. I have the creator stating it is for kids under 13. I love rubbing your old and lonely face in facts.
[b]Back in the day where there WASN'T a PG 13 rating. Back when you could get kind of Hardcore Under a G Rating. Unlike the moosh of your opinion. Movie Ratings Systems do change over time.Learn some History Munchink.
[/B]
Facts>flys imagination.
I grew up with both, its kind of a toss up for me, I love both. I would give the edge to the OT only because I like the SW universe as a whole more than the HP universe. The HP books are also much better than the movies, whereas the OT novels suck.
And yeah, Star wars has been altered so much, sometimes for the better but a lot of the time for the worse. As bad as it has gotten though from time to time, there still isn't a Star Wars novel or show/movie that is as bad as Cursed Child.
Originally posted by quanchi112
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.polygon.com/platform/amp/2017/4/13/15288998/george-lucas-star-wars-celebration
Eh. He said that when he was in full on Grumpy Old Man Grandpa Mode. Which came after his "I made Phantom Menace for muh Grandkids Bullshit" So yeah...Its a Crap Argument.
Originally posted by WolvesofBabylon
Star Wars, LOTR, MCU.. All better Universes compared to Potter.
As someone who isnt too big on LOTR or the original HP series, it does seem to me the HP craze carried on whereas the LOTR craze seemed very temporary (to me personally), even through the Hobbit trilogy.
Originally posted by FlyattractorWhen the creator says it was made for kids, the ratings board gave it a pg in my corner whereas Fly says huh uh in his corner. You do not have an argument. Two sources on my side whereas your goofy ass just closes his eyes and pretends reality is wrong. This is why you are a loser and sad loser. I had you at George Lucas, dummy.
[b]Eh. He said that when he was in full on Grumpy Old Man Grandpa Mode. Which came after his "I made Phantom Menace for muh Grandkids Bullshit" So yeah...Its a Crap Argument. [/B]
Originally posted by Darth ThorExcept Fly and others like wolves who had to be shown that Star Wars is far more childish than Harry Potter especially the later films.
Everyone know Star Wars was aimed at 12 year olds. But much like the HP series they allow it to go darker and more grown up as it progresses, because those same 12 year olds are 18 by the last one.That said the HP series just got too kiddish at times (FOR ME PERSONALLY).
Harry Potter gets much darker than any Star Wars film to date by the end of the series. Not even really debatable. The original Star Wars trilogy was not even that dark at any point imo. Funny thing is all the heroes survive in a true happy ending. Voldemort reeked much more havoc on the good guys in Harry Potter than Vader or Sidious.
They both get darker, as they both followed the same principle of "the kids who watched the first films, are adults by the end of the series".
I dunno ROTS and ESB were pretty dark, but I've not seen Deathly Hallows yet. Plan to watch both films over the weekend. So I will see then just how dark it gets.
But point is it was hard for me to even get there because of the kiddish stuff. Things like talking envelopes with lips just takes me out of it - ME PERSONALLY. Fantastic Beasts is also aimed at 12 year olds, I find the overall tone just more watchable. Might also be to do with the fact that the main characters are all kids for most of the HP series.
Originally posted by Darth ThorHarry Potter gets much darker and at the end they are not partying with Ewoks.
They both get darker, as they both followed the same principle of "the kids who watched the first films, are adults by the end of the series".I dunno ROTS and ESB were pretty dark, but I've not seen Deathly Hallows yet. Plan to watch both films over the weekend. So I will see then just how dark it gets.
But point is it was hard for me to even get there because of the kiddish stuff. Things like talking envelopes with lips just takes me out of it - ME PERSONALLY. Fantastic Beasts is also aimed at 12 year olds, I find the overall tone just more watchable. Might also be to do with the fact that the main characters are all kids for most of the HP series.
So you have yet to see the darkest films ffs. The films have been out for how many years so just as I thought. You are no fan. Just a casual movie goer with the franchise.
You cannot really even say since in your ignorance you have not seen the darkest of the films. You are just a casual movie goer here not even equipped to address this topic due to your own admitted lack of knowledge.
^ Thats great. I am expecting Quintin Tarantino style torture now the way you are going on about it.
I have already explained that I get the series is supposed to get darker as it goes along. That said I have seen 75% of the series and just found it too kiddish to really get into myself - PERSONALLY. Star Wars was never at those level of kiddishness for ME (save perhaps TPM with Jar Jar and 10year old Anakin in lead roles). But nicely balanced by the politics and Sith happenings for me.
Fantastic Beasts is more for me.