Rank these incarnations of Sidious, Mace and Anakin in sabers

Started by The Ellimist1 pages
The Ellimist The Shadow

Rank these incarnations of Sidious, Mace and Anakin in sabers

Anakin (S6)
Anakin (early/mid invisible hand fight)
Anakin (Zone state)
Anakin (Knightfall)
Sidious (BoTPM)
Sidious (EoTPM)
Sidious (RotS)
Sidious (DE)
Windu (TPM)
Windu (AotC)
Windu (S6)
Windu (RotS - no superconducting loop)
Windu (RotS - with Sidious's energies)

NewGuy01 perpetual

Is this a comparison of pure skill, or overall effectiveness?

The Ellimist The Shadow

Overall effectiveness

TenebrousWay God Tier Vaylin

Sidious (DE)
Windu (RotS - with Sidious's energies)
Anakin (Knightfall)
Sidious (RotS)
Anakin (Zone state)
Sidious (EoTPM)
Windu (RotS - no superconducting loop)
Anakin (early/mid invisible hand fight)
Windu (S6)
Sidious (BoTPM)
Anakin (S6)
Windu (AotC)
Windu (TPM)

TheNuisanceBird Wrecker - Scientist Class

Zonakin doesn’t exist.

NewGuy01 perpetual

RotS Vader
RotS Sidious / RotS Mace (vs Sidious)
RotS Anakin
RotS Mace
TPM Mace / TCW Anakin

Something along those lines. The differences between TPM/AotC Mace, TPM/RotS Sidious, "Zone"/"Knightfall" Anakin, and so on are pretty vaguely defined, so I stuck with what we know. No comment on DE Sidious.

CactusJoe Restricted

Originally posted by NewGuy01
RotS Vader
RotS Sidious / RotS Mace (vs Sidious)
RotS Anakin
RotS Mace
TPM Mace / TCW Anakin

Something along those lines. The differences between TPM/AotC Mace, TPM/RotS Sidious, "Zone"/"Knightfall" Anakin, and so on are pretty vaguely defined, so I stuck with what we know. No comment on DE Sidious.