Too many things going on. The army with the best advantage has to be the ones that can attack at max range while being able mobile enough to keep away from melee combat. However:
Individually if it were 1v1 armies, it would come down to Jedi or Hogwarts. But in a grand melee like this, there would be too many variables to predict a solid outcome. That and the fact that the smaller armies (Hogwarts and Jedis) have to deal with one major factor: Fatigue.
Jedis can skirmish and defend but one has to wonder if their stamina can hold out. Fight might take days or even weeks. They’d get no rest as they would be absolutely surrounded and likely bombarded by spells from afar.
Hogwarts have the advantage of range, power, versatility and mobility. But might get picked off one by one due to fatigue. They can’t rest either as they’d be surrounded as well and would be easily taken out by the jedi if they manage to get close enough.
Against ONLY the other armies, they would likely have insurmountable advantages, but due to the existence of each other, they may fall prey to sheer numbers of the fodder armies when they get tired enough. This is because they can’t rest/heal. As they would need a secure area for that. Troy would have been perfect but either army can easily breach the Troy walls, allowing the other fodder armies to pour through. Like I said, they counter each other enough that attrition will be a major factor and it’ll come down to w/c army has enough numbers to allow some of it to rest while the rest keep fighting/dying.
I would like to say Xerxes but their army is so shit individually (in both equipment and skill) that I can see them getting crushed by smaller yet far more potent armies.
So, in closing: Yeah, Idunno.
Originally posted by Nibedicus
Too many things going on. The army with the best advantage has to be the ones that can attack at max range while being able mobile enough to keep away from melee combat. However:Individually if it were 1v1 armies, it would come down to Jedi or Hogwarts. But in a grand melee like this, there would be too many variables to predict a solid outcome. That and the fact that the smaller armies (Hogwarts and Jedis) have to deal with one major factor: Fatigue.
Jedis can skirmish and defend but one has to wonder if their stamina can hold out. Fight might take days or even weeks. They’d get no rest as they would be absolutely surrounded and likely bombarded by spells from afar.
Hogwarts have the advantage of range, power, versatility and mobility. But might get picked off one by one due to fatigue. They can’t rest either as they’d be surrounded as well and would be easily taken out by the jedi if they manage to get close enough.
Against ONLY the other armies, they would likely have insurmountable advantages, but due to the existence of each other, they may fall prey to sheer numbers of the fodder armies when they get tired enough. This is because they can’t rest/heal. As they would need a secure area for that. Troy would have been perfect but either army can easily breach the Troy walls, allowing the other fodder armies to pour through. Like I said, they counter each other enough that attrition will be a major factor and it’ll come down to w/c army has enough numbers to allow some of it to rest while the rest keep fighting/dying.
I would like to say Xerxes but their army is so shit individually (in both equipment and skill) that I can see them getting crushed by smaller yet far more potent armies.
So, in closing: Yeah, Idunno.
This is gonna be one hell of a mess.
But on the long run I think the Jedi have the advantage. With commanders like Obi Wan and Mace Windu, i believe they can arm a good defence/offence.