Comic Book Questions & Discussion

Started by AlbertoJohnAvil1,926 pages

Originally posted by Astner
It doesn't have to. There's a limit to how large a star can get, and then there are object larger than stars, like quasars. Furthermore you have to content with the fact that it said star-shaking, not star-shattering.

And let's not forget Diana shoving a planet in the Darkest Knight's face.

You mean the Sun at the end of the issue?

😂 LMFAO those punches should not be able to hurt a being with supposedly MUltIvErSaLl durability.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
That's because abhi is being silly and being too focussed on this, whilst the Carvers and Albert's of this world try and tie him up and focus on this instead of anything else.
I have no quarrel with Abhi as a person, but I had 1 or 2 arguments with him in such a regard already. Also you don't need to make such things up to mock the usual suspects, they give you more than enough material non stop.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
All histories are now canon.

Everything else is window dressing. Superman is now towing multiple planets with a chain, casually.


That was Superboy, not Superman.

Anyway. So is Superman being unable to move the Earth, with help, also canon?

He got excited and blew his wad, it happens lol.

Is he SERIOUSLY saying Lex Luthor has the muscle strength to move a black hole, shrunken down? So in an arm wrestle, we need to put him up against Hulk? No.

Last Son was obviously very powerful, and was said to be a star. Even had the properties of one (helium/hydrogen core). Now, did he have the mass of one? All the questions you have about how it would work "in real life" kinda falls flat when Batman is running around whilst dead and resurrecting people left right and centre, oh, and WW just casually shrunk a planet into her hand and made DK eat it, lol.

Originally posted by Astner
That was Superboy, not Superman.

Anyway. So is Superman being unable to move the Earth, with help, also canon?

Superboy later grew up to become Superman, no?

Anyway. Yes, it is - all characters have low showings, after all.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
You said Lex couldn't push him like that, he never tried, you're jumping to conclusions and pump up feats for others while there's nothing to pump up. Just to make sure I am NOT questioning "Kill-All's" powerlevel just the mere fact that he's the weight of a star, which would directly translate as a feat for that metal Superman. He ambushed him and pushed a being a lot more powerful than him into space, Kill-All let it happen because he was laughing at him when he did it and mocked him when they reached their destination "So this is how the great Superman dies, look at you! Ugly, pathetic, alone."

He used energy blasts powered by a black hole?

Also he is laughing so his mass gets down to zero?

Tons of characters have absorbed a lot more shit and didn't increased their weight, it's comics mambojambo.

Actually, to destabilize the core its mass needs to increase.

Nope

That was before he was revealed as a living star (also written by a different writer).

Except of course that he ****ing burns yellow.

Actually the only real proof missing is that his weight actually equals a star.

Wait, he is a living star which burns yellow and is now weightless because Earth is not destroyed?

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
Stop shifting goalposts, address what I said dumbass 😂

😂

Originally posted by Astner
It doesn't have to. There's a limit to how large a star can get, and then there are object larger than stars, like quasars. Furthermore you have to content with the fact that it said star-shaking, not star-shattering.

And let's not forget Diana shoving a planet in the Darkest Knight's face.

You mean the Sun at the end of the issue?

This is terrible. Lol... planets have been the downfall of these characters.

WF and his brothers ran from a planet being thrown at them and admitted they would've died.

The combined force of Superman, Superboy Prime, Black Adam, Sinestro, etc.... used everything they had and couldn't destroy a single planet let alone the area they crashed into. Perpetua getting planets shoved in her face weakening her. BMWL being damaged by planets being shoved in his face. Galactus waves his hand and kills everyone in this war.

Originally posted by Astner
That was Superboy, not Superman.

Anyway. So is Superman being unable to move the Earth, with help, also canon?

What Darksaint said.

Longer story: I grew up during the Crisis transition. My earliest memories of DC comics are Man of Steel, following the reboot, and I followed Superman up until the "electric blue" transition.

I can not understate how much they "nerfed" him. He lost a fight against Mammoth and the Fatal Five, for crying out loud. He struggled with all his might to keep a single building from collapsing. He even struggled against the Helgramite, a Batman villian. This is no accident, DC made a conscious decision to show Superman using his wits, instead of punching his way to victory.

The effects of this era lasted for a long, long time. That's why fanboys held so hard onto the Imperiex Saga, and probe busting, because it took that long to get the kinds of combat feats fans of Hulk, or Xmen, or Marvel in general, got to see every month.

Originally posted by carver9
This is terrible. Lol... planets have been the downfall of these characters.

WF and his brothers ran from a planet being thrown at them and admitted they would've died.

The combined force of Superman, Superboy Prime, Black Adam, Sinestro, etc.... used everything they had and couldn't destroy a single planet let alone the area they crashed into. Perpetua getting planets shoved in her face weakening her. BMWL being damaged by planets being shoved in his face. Galactus waves his hand and kills everyone in this war.

😂

Originally posted by AlbertoJohnAvil
😂 I don't know anything about that kind of pseudo science, and I doubt Snyder does either. Also he was hovering right above ground level. If he weighed as much as a star, the earth would have been destroyed just from THAT. Not a "feat"
translation: I didn’t understand the google search results and couldn’t find a suitable reply on comicvine to copy and paste here as my own.

Originally posted by cdtm
What Darksaint said.

He was being ironic....

Originally posted by Astner
He was being ironic....

Are you sure?

I mean, have you seen him argue Batman? 🙂

Originally posted by carver9
This is terrible. Lol... planets have been the downfall of these characters.

WF and his brothers ran from a planet being thrown at them and admitted they would've died.

The combined force of Superman, Superboy Prime, Black Adam, Sinestro, etc.... used everything they had and couldn't destroy a single planet let alone the area they crashed into. Perpetua getting planets shoved in her face weakening her. BMWL being damaged by planets being shoved in his face. Galactus waves his hand and kills everyone in this war.

this is the most idiotic thing I have read in awhile.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Albert, you haven't explained how years passed on one earth, but only hours on Earth prime.

^^^^

Originally posted by carver9
This is terrible. Lol... planets have been the downfall of these characters.

WF and his brothers ran from a planet being thrown at them and admitted they would've died.

The combined force of Superman, Superboy Prime, Black Adam, Sinestro, etc.... used everything they had and couldn't destroy a single planet let alone the area they crashed into. Perpetua getting planets shoved in her face weakening her. BMWL being damaged by planets being shoved in his face. Galactus waves his hand and kills everyone in this war.


😂

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Main issues are:

SBP WASN'T an illusion;
All histories are now canon.

Everything else is window dressing. Superman is now towing multiple planets with a chain, casually. Throwing things through time, casually. Pushing planets, super ventriloquism, basket weaving, it's all canon.

What are you even talking about? No, "everything" in DC is not canon. 🤦

Except it is.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Albert, you haven't explained how years passed on one earth, but only hours on Earth prime.