Cap would win, imo.
A few hits from the edge of his shield to Shelob's head would be devastating, he could also easily remove limbs with a single swipe of the shield as he's cut through high tensile strength steel cables with it. (CA:CW)
I'd also question whether Shelob's paralyzing poison would work on Cap considering his body's superhuman ability to filter and neutralize toxins/inebriating compounds. (CA:TFA)
Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
I was going to point out something similar, but you beat me to it. Captain America >>>>> Samwise Gamgee. So, if he could give Shelob problems, Steve should win rather easily IMO.
In fairness, Shelob's weakness is light and the Phial contains the most pure and powerful light there is.
Cap still wins tho.
Originally posted by ares834
In fairness, Shelob's weakness is light and the Phial contains the most pure and powerful light there is.Cap still wins tho.
Yeah, but Steve has his pure inner Cap light, fueled by the power of being a century-old virgin, that shines through. 😄
Seriously though, if the guy can casually stomp a Quinjet (which is a large, bulletproof, flying opponent with a mounted minigun), I can't see a giant spider posing too much of a threat, unless Steve acts like an idiot, which is highly unlikely for an in-character Cap.