Sidious is to recruit a new aprentice, who does he pick?

Sidious needs help to choose between Kylo and Maul to be his new aprentice.

Who does he pick? Why?

Kylo certainly more potential, he is a Skywalker after all. Maul is just fodder in comparison; imagine Anakin before the lava dip and that's what Kylo can be basically

Kylo was trash. The worst person to ever wield a lightsaber.

Maul woulda killed Kylo in seconds in the forest

Maybe now, but I doubt he will be weak in the future.

Kylo has more potential than Maul.

Maul was one of the best ever.
I don't know many who were as skilled as he. I see him beating everyone except yoda, sidious, and mace.

Originally posted by h1a8
Maul was one of the best ever.
I don't know many who were as skilled as he. I see him beating everyone except yoda, sidious, and mace.

Smart. :3

Originally posted by h1a8
Maul was one of the best ever.
I don't know many who were as skilled as he. I see him beating everyone except yoda, sidious, and mace.

Originally posted by playa1258
Anakin and Obi-Wan have him beat too.

And Vader and Kanan (lulz) and therefore likely countless others.

Originally posted by Eon Blue
Kylo has more potential than Maul.

👆

Darth Andeddu kicks everyone’s asses. ;3

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Kylo was trash. The worst person to ever wield a lightsaber.

Maul woulda killed Kylo in seconds in the forest

maybe so, but if he was trained by Sidious instead of that crippled **** Snoke he would've been a badass

Kylo due to force potential.

I was thinking based on feats, I mean, both contest for the worst SW villain, at least moviewise.

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
I was thinking based on feats, I mean, both contest for the worst SW villain, at least moviewise.

Originally posted by victreebelvictr
How about based on potential? ;3

There is no certainty basing it on that. I mean, thr Jedi recruited Anakin based on his potential and yet he disappointed them.

Samething with Kylo. Snoke confessed that he wasn't what he expected.

So, I was thinking based on feats.

Im going off feats. Kylo was trash and so was snoke.

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Im going off feats. Kylo was trash and so was snoke.

Kylo was a massive disappointment I agree. But movie Maul wasn't that great either.

Originally posted by relentless1
Kylo certainly more potential, he is a Skywalker after all. Maul is just fodder in comparison; imagine Anakin before the lava dip and that's what Kylo can be basically

Originally posted by Nevan
What was Sidious' plan if Anakin wasn't crippled?

its implied in ROTS that Sidious knew and was OK with Anakin usurping him when he was powerful enough...

(to Yoda) "Darth Vader will become more powerful than either of us"