Magneto versus Martian Manhunter · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

AlbertoJohnAvil Restricted

Magneto versus Martian Manhunter

Base Peak
Morals: Off
Prep: None
Gear: Standard
Interference: Off
Location: X-Mansion; 60 ft apart
Victory Conditions: Death/KO/Incap

Damborgson King of the Damboys

The Martian would be too much sadly.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Originally posted by Damborgson
The Martian would be too much sadly.

Because Mags in the pic is nerfed?

Or because you think Mags can't take care of the biggest jobber in the herald tier that DC has to offer...?

Damborgson King of the Damboys

The second one.

Mags wouldn't get creamed or anything but I do genuinely think that Manhunter on here where he wont suffer from typical jobber behavior will take him down.

Sin I AM Madame Mort

Has Magneto ever taken down a herald tiered character?

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Has Magneto ever taken down a herald tiered character?

Exodus...

Phoenix...

Vision...

Originally posted by Damborgson
The second one.
Mags wouldn't get creamed or anything but I do genuinely think that Manhunter on here where he wont suffer from typical jobber behavior will take him down.

So you want us to ignore most of J'onn's showings? 😛

MM literally had his own section (dozens of pages) in the Ownage thread years back.

It was so bad, one member had the links put in his signature.

Sin I AM Madame Mort

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Exodus...
Phoenix...
Vision...
So you want us to ignore most of J'onn's showings? 😛
MM literally had his own section (dozens of pages) in the Ownage thread years back.
It was so bad, one member had the links put in his signature.

Oh yea...i forgot about those 👌

StiltmanFTW CBvF

I'm sure he has more notable fights against heralds... but I want to allow Phil to flex his muscles when he posts in this thread.

Not mentioning Apocalypse, as it technically always took place either in some alternate universe or a simulation.

zopzop Lord of the Great Abyss

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Exodus...
Phoenix...
Vision...

I don't know if I'd qualify Exodus or Vision as heralds, more like elite high metas. And the Phoenix win (assuming you mean the time they fought in the late 70s) was against a gimped Jean. She subconsciously put up psionic circuit breakers after the M'krann Crystal incident. They weren't broken till she went Dark Phoenix much, much later.

Damborgson King of the Damboys

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
So you want us to ignore most of J'onn's showings? 😛
MM literally had his own section (dozens of pages) in the Ownage thread years back.
It was so bad, one member had the links put in his signature.

Wish I could have seen that...we rarely do that anymore 🙁

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Originally posted by zopzop
I don't know if I'd qualify Exodus or Vision as heralds

KMC qualified them. We've got a new tiers thread.

But aside from that... Exodus is so bloody versatile and has such insane team-wrecking showings, pretending he's a mere high meta is crazy, imo 😛

Jean is one of those characters who is NEVER at her peak, she always have an excuse.

We could use White Phoenix of the Crown version and some would still argue that "True Jean" is at her best WITHOUT the Phoenixforce... 😂 I'm not even kidding, that's what recent comics are trying to say.

She's like that True Darkseid bs --- there'll always be an excuse.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Anyway, Mags also beat her ass in Morrison Era, although that was with Kick.

AlbertoJohnAvil Restricted

It's arguable Mags can KO him, he has subatomic control so it's not farfetched that he can kill him

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Immortal Herc got beaten by Mags, too.

leonidas MWHAHAHAHA!

mags broke free of herc's grip if that's what you mean. he also defeated proteus who was definitely a herald. but he hasn't really beaten a herald one on one that i can recall. iron man is a low herald imo. not saying he can't beat heralds--he def has feats and versatility to do so, but as an x-men villain he's usually beating up on them for most of his career...

the unusually high amount of iron in jonn's blood would be the end of him in this match though. mags also has lots of other avenues of attack here though. i'd def take mags in this for a majority. this has also been done MULTIPLE TIMES and will likely be closed if spotted. use the damn search for once.....

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Originally posted by leonidas
mags broke free of herc's grip if that's what you mean.

No, I mean what happened afterwards.

Stop pretending you forgot.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Originally posted by leonidas
but he hasn't really beaten a herald one on one that i can recall.

Lol.

It's Magneto who is always outnumbered.

lawest9 Senior Member

Manhunter for the win, intangibility rules.

StyleTime Senior Member

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW

Jean is one of those characters who is NEVER at her peak, she always have an excuse.
We could use White Phoenix of the Crown version and some would still argue that "True Jean" is at her best WITHOUT the Phoenixforce... 😂 I'm not even kidding, that's what recent comics are trying to say.
She's like that True Darkseid bs --- there'll always be an excuse.

👆

Her statement about holding back due the Phoenix looks like it was true.

Jean completely ignored a full on telepathic assault from Cassandra Nova recently.
https://postimg.cc/KK9bT79S
https://postimg.cc/qtrYL481
https://postimg.cc/NKmSm5ry

Jean "loses" eventually
https://postimg.cc/xcGWHyCx

...except Jean was just playing dead. She was setting Nova up for Gabby to hit Nova with a personality altering nanite. And Jean explains she wasn't trying to kill Cassandra, but wanted to heal her instead.
https://postimg.cc/TprX0vkc
https://postimg.cc/G8ZZPXGN
https://postimg.cc/7GCFTFG0

As you said, "True Jean" strikes again! Even an out-to-kill Cassandra couldn't take her out and Jean wasn't even using her "real" power. Jean doesn't need the weak ass Phoenix yo.

Senor Cage Senior Member

Battle is pretty simple. If MM uses his powers, he wins. If not, Magneto wins. Nothing Magneto can do when MM phases into another dimension and one-shots him.