The Rock that Hurt Thor vs. Superman

Originally posted by Stoic
Superman doesn't tank everything. You're doing it again DS. If Carver looked for scans that only show Superman being stunned by things that should have little to no effect on him, the Superman Society would spin out of their skins calling lowball. Plot dictates that certain things will happen in these stories. For instance Thor in that very story is hit by by far greater forces than that boulder and continued to fight. This is clearly a case of cherry picking.

When he's amped by the equivalent of the Odin Force and the Power Cosmic he does.

I am not cherry picking. He's literally been shown for what, one issue? 2? This is literally half his appearances lol.

But if you want to show AMPED Superman being downed by the equivalent, then go for it. Put your scans where your mouth is

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Now that you mention it, getting dunked over the head with a boulder is such an important plot point. It makes sense now.

You're right, Alberto.

It’s not exactly crucial, but it does show that Thor is willing to help people he deems innocent, even if they are hostile towards him.

Even if they hurt him, you mean

Well, I can see that Khazra.

But at the same time, they could have just as easily made the boulder bounce off of him portraying his supposed status as the cosmic All-Father tbf.

Could have. But at the end of the day does it really matter? One page later a planet explodes on his head. It’s obvious the rock didn’t do anything.

Maybe the planet was just an hallucination caused by the boulder. 🤔

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Could have. But at the end of the day does it really matter? One page later a planet explodes on his head. It’s obvious the rock didn’t do anything.

It does when he's done almost nothing with his new gifts, and is being touted as a combo of Surfer and Odin plus Thor, lol.

UNH!!!

He took far more abuse than that boulder though. It's as if you guys sit in the cut waiting for a low showing to happen which then gives you a good reason to parade it around while ignoring the fact that all characters have them.

Originally posted by Stoic
He took far more abuse than that boulder though. It's as if you guys sit in the cut waiting for a low showing to happen which then gives you a good reason to parade it around while ignoring the fact that all characters have them.

Then you are ignoring my two rebuttals to your point.

1. Not all characters have what is the Odinforce AND the Power Cosmic with them, on top of already being one of the top heralds in comics.

2. Waiting for a low showing? Its literally Thor ISSUE NUMBER TWO, lol. He's had like one issue with both these newfound amps, and he's already having a showing so low it would've disgraced normal Thor, let alone Herald Thor. Aren't you the one who always talks about averages?

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Nope. The same way you don't assume an alternate versions' power level.

What was the missiles made out of? Until proof is shown, these are standard missiles. Sorry!!! 🙂

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Well, I can see that Khazra.

But at the same time, they could have just as easily made the boulder bounce off of him portraying his supposed status as the cosmic All-Father tbf.

The boulders were made out of adamantium thrown by beings just as strong as Doomsday.

So in Carver's opinion, Doomsday is enough to hurt Odinforce Thor amped with the PC lmao.

Thor? Sure. But ODINFORCE, PC AMPED THOR?

Didn't Odin tank galaxy level explosions or somesuch?

It's def a massive low showing.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
It does when he's done almost nothing with his new gifts, and is being touted as a combo of Surfer and Odin plus Thor, lol.

UNH!!!

No it doesn’t. If he easily withstands an attack, that is potentially millions of times more potent, seconds later, any thinking person would come to the conclusion that the rock didn’t do anything. Never mind the fact there was nothing to indicate it hurt him anyways, other than saying un, which is weak AF.

If Superman had tanked a supernova and then later on bloodied by a rock saint would've went with the precedence

And the expression on his face, which a pro artist took time to lovingly sketch, draw and ink, is totally him just orgasming at the thought of being so powerful 👆

Hey, it's a low showing. It happens to all. It just so happens it'sSO low for a character touted to be this high....

Originally posted by carver9
@Squall...

You do know Batman shot SuperMAN Prime with some rockets and hurt him, right? Amped Superboy Prime screamed out from rocket by Batman jet.

First, this Superman! Not Prime

Second, when did this happened?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
And the expression on his face, which a pro artist took time to lovingly sketch, draw and ink, is totally him just orgasming at the thought of being so powerful 👆

Hey, it's a low showing. It happens to all. It just so happens it'sSO low for a character touted to be this high....

Or, he could have just been surprised that a group of people he was trying to save, metaphorically stabbed him in the back.

Originally posted by carver9
What was the missiles made out of? Until proof is shown, these are standard missiles. Sorry!!! 🙂

Originally posted by carver9
The boulders were made out of adamantium thrown by beings just as strong as Doomsday.

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Or, he could have just been surprised that a group of people he was trying to save, metaphorically stabbed him in the back.

Just surprised?

He was on his damn knees, lol.