Ideal Tier List

If you were given the power to be able to choose the order of the overall power (combination of force ability & saber skill) of different duelists/force users what would it be?

It make logical sense for the story and or be able to be explained somehow. For example putting Quinlan Vos or Ventress above Sidious would most likely not make sense. My list would go something like this:

Luke Skywalker [ST]
Palpatine [ROTJ]
Yoda
Vader
Mace Windu
Mother Talzin
----------------
Anakin Skywalker
Kylo Ren
Count Dooku
Quinlan Vos
Luke Skywalker [ROTJ]
Rey
-----------------
Darth Maul
Kenobi
General Grievous
Kit Fisto
Plo Koon
Ventress
Other Council Members
----------------
Savage
Grand Inquisitor
Unimportant characters........

Good list. Palpatine should be at the top though

I'm fine with the list except for Kylo and Rey, whom I think should be much lower (like at least a couple of tiers). Maybe even putting Kenobi and Maul in the tier above, but overall it's good. Mine would be:

Tier 1:
Mortis Anakin
Father
Son
Daughter
Force Priestesses

Tier 2:
All-Jedi Rey
All-Sith Sidious

Tier 3:
Luke Skywalker
RotJ Sidious
Snoke
Yoda
Bendu

Tier 3:
Darth Vader
Mace Windu
Quinlan Vos
Darth Tyranus
Obi Wan Kenobi
Darth Maul
Ahsoka Tano
Mother Talzin

Tier 5:
Assajj Ventress
General Grevious
Savage Oppress
Kylo Ren
Rey
Kit Fisted
Plo Koon

Tier 6:
Other councilors
GI
Barriss Offee

I may move Vader up a tier because he seems more powerful in canon

Yeah. Overall I just would want Kylo to be more powerful since he's of Skywalker bloodline and trained by Luke Skywalker. At the age of 30 I would hope for him to be a little below Anakin level.

^Yeah, some of his feats are cool, but imo he is not that impressive. He struggled to defeat Rey who had only 1 year worth of training, he killed the knight of Ren's leader but they are all legit padawan tier

Yeah Kylo definitely isn't that powerful as put, but that's more just what I would actually like to have him be at, not what he is actually at.

Originally posted by Total Warrior
^Yeah, some of his feats are cool, but imo he is not that impressive. He struggled to defeat Rey who had only 1 year worth of training, he killed the knight of Ren's leader but they are all legit padawan tier

Kylo should be near ROTS Anakin/ROTJ Luke level based on his bloodline and years of training.

Originally posted by xPRIMEx
He really didn't struggle at all against her, and even though she only had 1 year of training her growth was accelerated by her dyad with Kylo. Also Luke only had a few years of training yet he was Vader's equal by ROTJ.

Kylo should be near ROTS Anakin/ROTJ Luke level based on his bloodline and years of training.

Originally posted by Total Warrior
I'm fine with the list except for Kylo and Rey, whom I think should be much lower (like at least a couple of tiers). Maybe even putting Kenobi and Maul in the tier above, but overall it's good. Mine would be:

Tier 1:
Mortis Anakin
Father
Son
Daughter
Force Priestesses

Tier 2:
All-Jedi Rey
All-Sith Sidious

Tier 3:
Luke Skywalker
RotJ Sidious
Snoke
Yoda
Bendu

Tier 3:
Darth Vader
Mace Windu
Quinlan Vos
Darth Tyranus
Obi Wan Kenobi
Darth Maul
Ahsoka Tano
Mother Talzin

Tier 5:
Assajj Ventress
General Grevious
Savage Oppress
Kylo Ren
Rey
Kit Fisted
Plo Koon

Tier 6:
Other councilors
GI
Barriss Offee

I may move Vader up a tier because he seems more powerful in canon

I agree. 👆