Originally posted by TheHulkster
I mean, why does being alternate matter? Why is it ruled against?
As KT says (thanks btw for pointing this out):
Young Thanos, in all his battles with Surfer, has never faced this foe.
NEVER.
So this 'Fallen One' is different from 616 Surfer that 616 Thanos has fought.
And if they are different, then.....no, they don't get to share feats.