Originally posted by Impediment
The OT is superior in every way. CGI doesn't make a film special or better. The OT has better story telling, characterization, plot, pacing, acting, and no nods to society and the culture we live in today just to appease snowflakes and libtards.The PT is good, even if Phantom Menace should have been sponsored by Cheese Whiz.
The ST is just not that good to me. No heart, no soul, no loyalty to the original fans who grew up with the beloved franchise. I totally understand that Star Wars has to change the formula to attract in and keep fans of a new generation, but the ST destroyed the foundation of greatness that took decades to build.
👆
My only disagreement is that they have to change the formula. Refine it, maybe, but you can go on youtube and watch kids watching the OT and their reactions to it.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Ridiculous. Iyo not mine. Your own feelings are the only thing hurt. Toxic fandom claiming Disney ignores fan loyalty just because you let politics invade your judgment. The same fandom went wild on G Lucas over the the Pt. Fans need to get a life and realize your own opinion is your own. You do not own Star Wars nor do you speak for everyone. If you claim the terrible acting from the Ot trilogy is better I do not trust your opinion. You can enjoy it more but to lie not only to me but yourself shows you have too many political inspired feelings to think clearly. Better action, better storytelling, deeper meaning, and yes better cgi which is just a nice bow tie to the superiority of these films. Originals will always be more impactful but just set aside your nostalgia in the future.
He's a troll, ignore him. The relationship between Kylo and Rey is the best thing that's happened in these films.
"No heart no soul"
F ucking moron. They gave creative control to the design team in TFA. They used the same concept design from scratch that Ralph McQuarrie did for Star Wars. They used props, set pieces and shot onset locations. They let a director write and direct the second film inserting his own artistic integrity into the film. Interesting themes like Hero worship and identity were implemented. And these actors all feel like human beings instead of the cartoon characters that came before them.
OT of course, not only does it have the best single movie "The Empire Strikes Back", the overall story of the three films is superior to the other two trilogies. I watch one or more of these every few years still.
I liked the PT overall as well. On [rare] occasion watch ep 2 or 3 still.
ST, did like the first film, but it went down hill considerably, the story didn't move me. I honestly can say I am fine never watching ep 7-9 again.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Ridiculous. Iyo not mine. Your own feelings are the only thing hurt. Toxic fandom claiming Disney ignores fan loyalty just because you let politics invade your judgment. The same fandom went wild on G Lucas over the the Pt. Fans need to get a life and realize your own opinion is your own. You do not own Star Wars nor do you speak for everyone. If you claim the terrible acting from the Ot trilogy is better I do not trust your opinion. You can enjoy it more but to lie not only to me but yourself shows you have too many political inspired feelings to think clearly. Better action, better storytelling, deeper meaning, and yes better cgi which is just a nice bow tie to the superiority of these films. Originals will always be more impactful but just set aside your nostalgia in the future.
Would you like some cheese with your whine?
Originally posted by Ayelewis
He's a troll, ignore him. The relationship between Kylo and Rey is the best thing that's happened in these films."No heart no soul"
F ucking moron. They gave creative control to the design team in TFA. They used the same concept design from scratch that Ralph McQuarrie did for Star Wars. They used props, set pieces and shot onset locations. They let a director write and direct the second film inserting his own artistic integrity into the film. Interesting themes like Hero worship and identity were implemented. And these actors all feel like human beings instead of the cartoon characters that came before them.
nopity
Originally posted by quanchi112
Ridiculous. Iyo not mine. Your own feelings are the only thing hurt. Toxic fandom claiming Disney ignores fan loyalty just because you let politics invade your judgment. The same fandom went wild on G Lucas over the the Pt. Fans need to get a life and realize your own opinion is your own. You do not own Star Wars nor do you speak for everyone. If you claim the terrible acting from the Ot trilogy is better I do not trust your opinion. You can enjoy it more but to lie not only to me but yourself shows you have too many political inspired feelings to think clearly. Better action, better storytelling, deeper meaning, and yes better cgi which is just a nice bow tie to the superiority of these films. Originals will always be more impactful but just set aside your nostalgia in the future.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Harrison Ford is awful in some of these. He got much better but the acting is sub par. This series blows it out of the water. Mark H. was just a voice and Luke because he is not a great actor by any stretch of the imagination.
Originally posted by quanchi112
You might like them better but in terms of acting Driver, Ridley, and Isaac are just better actors. Ford got so much better with time but was still under developed at the time. Ian is in this Star Wars too. Watch the films. You might like them better but it is really sub par especially ANH in terms of acting.
Originally posted by Impediment
Would you like some cheese with your whine?
Ohh I ACKBAR'ed This One!!!!
Originally posted by Jmanghan
You didn't like RoTJ? 🙁
I think "dreadful" is harsh criticism, so I'll take that back. I think it's disappointing but overall a solid and fun movie. What kills Jedi for me is Fisher and Ford, their roles here are so insipid, they're just props to move the story forward on Endor. I don't mind having alien creature allies but why Ewoks?. There is something so silly about ROTJ, it's off putting. Compared to Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back, they definitely ran out of ideas in terms of writing and interesting thematic material.
Originally posted by Darth ThorIyo not mine. Nostalgia has clouded your judgment. Action in the Ot is terrible as is a lot of the acting. Kylo surpassed Vader in terms of evil and deed. Love it. He was even a better hero in the end than Vader.
OT amongst the greatest trilogies of all time (if not greatest).PT & OT form one of the greatest sagas of all time. And even More so when including TCW.
ST is just 😂
Puts the entire saga down tbh.