Both at their best and peak in a light saber duel only: No force powers , who wins in both: Canon and Legends ?
SCI
ScizardSenior Member
Darth Sidious is far above Kenobi
MCP
McPSenior Member
THE SORESU master guard is impenetrable. And since there is no Anakin there, The Soresu wont be distracted.
GAL
Galan007|Quantum Observer|
Wasn't it stated in The Jedi Path that Juyo can shred through the defenses of Soresu? I don't browse Legends much at all these days, so I could be mistaken.
Gillard's tiering system also has Palpatine well above Kenobi in saber combat, iirc.
JED
JediMaster97Senior Member
To be fair, since some people now believe that Vader>Sidious in lightdaber combat (in canon), doesn't that make ANH Obi-Wan at least somewhat equal to Sidious in sabers?
If he can hang with Vader, why not with Sidious?
GAL
Galan007|Quantum Observer|
Canon makes it clear that Kenobi had absolutely no chance of beating Vader in ANH.
MCP
McPSenior Member
This shitsney canon cannot makes anything. It suck ;/
MCP
McPSenior Member
Anyway, in Legends, it might be possible that Kenobi would be one shoted by palpatine, even in sabers. Or alone would do as well as Kit supported by Windu. A one-sided fight anyway.