Aragorn vs. Geralt of Rivia

Standard gear.

Round 1: Movie version of Aragorn, tv show version of Geralt
Round 2: Book versions

Geralt would utterly wreck Aragorn.

Originally posted by jaden_2.0
Geralt would utterly wreck Aragorn.

Gerald kicks his teeth down his throat.

Even tv version?

Originally posted by xPRIMEx
Even tv version?

Aragorn is stronger then him, Geralt is most likely faster and FAR more skilled.

Geralt wins.

Geralt FTW.

I gotta go w. the guy from my hometown. 😛

Geralt doesn’t really have any feats in the tv show that are better than Aragorn’s though. Yeah, if this is composite Geralt he wins, but im talking about tv show feats only for Geralt. The only magic he’s used in combat so far is that “force-push” which doesn’t do much, and his sword fighting doesn’t seem any better than Aragorn’s

Netflix Geralt is a lot faster, as he blocked 2 crossbow bolts from close range, and wasn't even looking at one of them.

And his Aard actually can blast a Kikimora 30 feet down a hallway so hard it crushes stone. He just didn't use it full force on humans. And while he doesn't have many lifting feats, his striking feats especially against monsters make it competitive.

Game version of Geralt is too powerful to use.

Against the Striga you mean? Yeah I forgot about that, that was nice. That would definitely **** Aragorn up if he uses it, but it’s not something that he’ll spam.

The fact that Renfri was able to hit Geralt a few times makes me think that Aragorn would have a chance though. She’s only human, whereas Aragorn is near superhuman.

Yeah the Striga is what I meant, and he doesn't need to spam it. One good blast will do a whole lotta damage.

As for Renfri, in both the books and the show, she is stated to be a mutant and more than human. They don't go into full detail but it's Stregebor in both mediums and Renfri herself in Netflix who point out she's not normal.

Stregebor was the one that said she was cursed and a mutant but I wouldn’t take his word for it that guy was full of shit

Actually you're right, I just remembered that Renfri was able to control the minds of those men in Blaviken, and Geralt's magic didn't work on her.

I don't think she had enhanced combat abilities though.

If Geralt lands a solid hit with his Aard ability, Aragorn is probably screwed. If not, and it comes down to a swordfight, I think it could go either way.

Geralt stomps

Why?

Aragorn isn't just human. He is Dunedain--a descendant of Numenoreans. Therefore he has enhanced strength and stamina. He even has some elven and Maia blood too. He's almost 90 years old so he has plenty of experience. He should be able to at least compete with Geralt.

I'm gonna have to agree with Prime on this one.

It seems like a lot of you are either underrating Aragorn or overrating Geralt here. Netflix Geralt isn't as OP as he is in the video games. Don't get me wrong he's still a beast, but so is Aragorn. This would be a good fight.

Geralt really didn't wanna be fighting Renfri. His heart wasn't in it.