Luke Skywalker vs Darth Vadar

Luke Skywalker: The Mandelorian

Vs

Rogue One Darth Vadar

I picked these two because these were probably the best showings for both characters in all of SW in their prime, brief but very powerful showings.

Who wins?

Link to feats

Originally posted by BrolyBlack
Luke Skywalker: The Mandelorian

Vs

Rogue One Darth Vadar

I picked these two because these were probably the best showings for both characters in all of SW in their prime, brief but very powerful showings.

Who wins?

Luke easily I think. Vader was taking on random fodder while Luke was destroying Dark Troopers

Luke should be better by 9 ABY. He was already stated to be Vader’s equal as of rotj

To be fair badas could have done the same thing.

I would say Vader because of the fact he was working in tighter quarters I think.

Though I can possibly go with Luke if persuaded.

Luke's showing is vastly more impressive from a feats standpoint due to what he was fighting.

Vader's scene was still the cooler scene overall though, what with the music and him slaughtering good guys versus Luke cutting down machines.

I think Like feat was more impressive but I don’t doubt Vader could easily accomplish the same feat.

Originally posted by xPRIMEx
Luke should be better by 9 ABY. He was already stated to be Vader’s equal as of rotj

Yeah but its a stupid quote which makes Luke too much like Rey.

Mandalorian Luke on the other hand, can be pitted against any top tier without any logic gymnastics.

If we're talking about which showing was superior in terms of feats, then Luke's by far. Vader killed ~12 fodder Rebel troops in the corridor. Luke casually raped something like 30 Dark Troopers(which are presumably among the most advanced/elite droids ever constructed.)

If we're just talking about which showing was more badass overall, however, then probably Vader's... Though Luke's is definitely right there with it.

it should be luke but darth could get stronger with better technology

Luke. He was already Vader's equal in ROTJ. Now he's got 5 years of more experience and growth.

As for which scene was better: I’m a huge Vader fan and as much as I loved his hallway scene in Rogue One, I have to say that Luke’s scene in Mandalorian was even better. The build up, the music, the dark troopers, everything was amazing.

^👆

Thought Luke's hallway scene was kinda meh compared to Vader's/Mauls ngl, Luke is probably the superior combatant by 9ABY though.

It was way cooler than Maul’s. Vader’s was more interesting though.

I dunno man, the choregraphy just felt very meh to me, didn't have that little effort vibes all the way through like Vader/Maul did.

I'm guessing we're gonna be getting more hallway scenes now though lol. It'll be fun to rank them all as time goes on, for now:

Vader
Maul
Luke

Maul's was kinda dumb honestly in the way it played out.

Luke's is more badass because fought tougher opponents and it had better build up.