1. Light sabers 2. H2H 3. Force powers 4. All out fight with all of the above
TW
Total WarriorDark Councilor
It's hard for me to say it but Windu wins 🙁
UND
Underachiever59Senior Member
Mace takes it, in my opinion. Especially if this is Legends we're talking about here.
Canon, you could argue it's a bit closer, since both have fought roughly evenly against Count Dooku. However, Mace's feat against Sidious just puts him outside of Quinlan's reach.