Hercules vs Ikaris

1.h2h only and physical powers only.

2. Herc gets his mace but can he close in fast enough to ward off Ikaris range attacks?

1) It's close and can go either way. They sort of fought in an issue of Hercules back in the mid 2010s. It was Hercules and Athena vs Ikaris and Thena. It wasn't looking good for the Olympians.
2) Ikaris definitely wins.