Magik vs Hela

Started by DarkSaint853 pages

Carvy, hello!

Re: Magik vs Hela

Originally posted by cdtm
In Limbo.

If Magik wins, classic Odin is next, followed by White Crown Phoenix, followed by Galactus, followed by Lord Morpheus.

Basically looking at what level Magik is at in limbo.

Can't see Hela defeating her. while she's in her place of power, Limbo. Even while Hela had a bunch of impressive feats in her guest appearances of Guardians of the Galaxy.

Not sure Odin could defeat her in Limbo either.

Beyond that, possibly. Galactus, I'd give the surest shot since he directly took on Mephisto in his realm.

👆 yet somehow, Carvster thinks she's overrated.

Originally posted by carver9
Magik is overrated

Is she now....

She's still overrated.

Originally posted by ODG
Can't see Hela defeating her. while she's in her place of power, Limbo. Even while Hela had a bunch of impressive feats in her guest appearances of Guardians of the Galaxy.

Not sure Odin could defeat her in Limbo either.

Beyond that, possibly. Galactus, I'd give the surest shot since he directly took on Mephisto in his realm.

Take ODG down a peg or two. This fool thinks Odin can't do it, and Big G is only 'possible'.

Originally posted by carver9
She's still overrated.

She can hit with the force of supernovas.

Naah, I'm not responding to ODG. Also, one showing doesn't dictate a characters history. Especially when beings like Spiderman has survived an explosion from the UN, withstood a beating from the Phoenix Five and outright thrashed Heralds. Amazing ft for her, though, but we need a collection of showings.

Originally posted by carver9
Naah, I'm not responding to ODG. Also, one showing doesn't dictate a characters history. Especially when beings like Spiderman has survived an explosion from the UN, withstood a beating from the Phoenix Five and outright thrashed Heralds. Amazing ft for her, though, but we need a collection of showings.

Only one showing?
And why not respond? He's overrating her no? Not even I said Odin....

Look at what Amanda Sefton, using Magik's Soul Sword, did to Mephisto in his realm :

I think she'd beat Hela in or out of Hel.

OP put the fight in Limbo lol. Her place of power

Carv, still after that collection of showings?

We have two fights against Dormmamu, 2 showings against Cyttorak so far - am sure thre are more.

in limbo she beats odin i think, let alone hela. pretty sure limbo was considered to be above the splinter realms, of which hel is just one. that sword would eat hela. phoenix is tough to say--not enough solid showings to decide one way or the other and it's really hard to say what that sword would do to the phoenix entity itself since it isn't magical. galactus would beat her--or eat limbo. amounts to the same thing.

She's not currently the ruler of Limbo right? I thought it was still Madelyne Pryor. Unless I missed Magik taking back her title.

Obviously this thread was made back before she gave up the throne. But I don't think Limbo gave her any extra help for that "force of a supernova" feat.

It's still Madelyne, but no, Limbo didn't help her - shitty comic writing did.

👆

yeah i'm assuming the thread was meant to be while she was the ruler. 👆

Originally posted by carver9
Naah, I'm not responding to ODG. Also, one showing doesn't dictate a characters history. Especially when beings like Spiderman has survived an explosion from the UN, withstood a beating from the Phoenix Five and outright thrashed Heralds. Amazing ft for her, though, but we need a collection of showings.

It does dictate a character's history when it suits you.

And you compared a character with hundreds if not thousands of appearances to a minor character, to argue "one showing doesn't dictate a character's history."

Even now she can still call upon the demons to help her fight.