Which Marvel Character...

did they nail and which got totally ruined in the MCU?

In my opinion...

Nailed it:

Iron Man
Kingpin
Punisher
Daredevil
Thanos
Dr. Strange
Black Panther (T'Challa)

****ed up:

Adam Warlock
Ronan The Accuser
The Collector
Thor
Gorr the Godbutcher
Valkyrie
Sif

Sif was alright I thought. I thought Cap was pretty spot on too.

Oh man, this is going to be a popular thread...

Thor, easily.

Ragnarok and Love & Thunder were so f*cking stupid. They wasted Planet Hulk and turned him into a comedic character.

Fúck knows. I don't read comics. They could all be spot on or absolutely fúcking miles away and I wouldn't know either way.

I HAVE NO IDEA BUT

Originally posted by Thinkerer
did they nail and which got totally ruined in the MCU?

In my opinion...

Nailed it:

Iron Man
Kingpin
Punisher
Daredevil
Thanos
Dr. Strange
Black Panther (T'Challa)

****ed up:

Adam Warlock
Ronan The Accuser
The Collector
Thor
Gorr the Godbutcher
Valkyrie
Sif

YOU TELL ME

None. They all suck a fat baby's dick.

for me the ones ****ed up

Malekith
Kro
Crossbones

All of them.

Originally posted by Kazenji
for me the ones ****ed up

Malekith
Kro
Crossbones

Oh yeah so true, though I dont have much issue with Crossbones.

Also:

Whiplash
MODOK

Originally posted by Old Man Whirly!
All of them.

Nailed it or F**ked up?

deadpool, if he's allowed, is probably the most spot on character in the mcu to date.

others that were abysmal are-
galactus (from FF 2)
doom (from the most recent FF movie)
taskmaster
kang

Originally posted by Thinkerer
Oh yeah so true, though I dont have much issue with Crossbones.

My problem i think is that they set him to make him look like comic crossbones, Only for him to be taken out in the first 15 mins of Civil War. He had alot more potential to stay around.

Whiplash
MODOK

****ed up or spot on?

Originally posted by DeadpoolXXX
others that were abysmal are-
galactus (from FF 2)
doom (from the most recent FF movie)

Neither of those were MCU. The jury's out on Deadpool; the next film will probably still be isolated from MCU, happening in its own self-contained universe.

The first Doom was quite a disappointment as well, being more of Electro than Doom.

Third time's a charm, here's hoping.

Originally posted by Patient_Leech
Nailed it or F**ked up?

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW

The first Doom was quite a disappointment as well, being more of Electro than Doom.

Third time's a charm, here's hoping.

The Doom from the 94 unreleased was more comic accurate.

I think Captain America, Iron-Man, Spider-Man and Thor were very well cast.

There's other good casting picks, but I feel most of the MCU did well with actor selection. Where the MCU fails is the writing, especially from Phase 4 onward.

Originally posted by Kazenji
My problem i think is that they set him to make him look like comic crossbones, Only for him to be taken out in the first 15 mins of Civil War. He had alot more potential to stay around.

****ed up or spot on?

Majorly ****ed up. With his battle armor covering his face he looked somewhat okay, but without it, it was horrible.

Originally posted by tkitna
Sif was alright I thought. I thought Cap was pretty spot on too.

Cap wasnt bad, same with Spiderman, but whether they were great, im not sure.

More ****ed up:

Malekith
Skurge