Didn't realize someone made this thread.
Oldman Drac wins. Shrugged off getting shot in Man-Bat form, can shapeshift into a 7-foot tall werewolf, and - big bonus here - is just mildly inhibited by sunlight as Bram Stoker wrote the character, rather than immediately dying. His sense of fashion is also far above Count Orlok's, cool and crisp as a cucumber vs. some old robes and rags.
Count Orlok has the mind control thing, but that isn't working on Dracula, as that's one of his powers too. He does have a sick mustache though.