Superman (DCEU) vs. MCU Galactus

Started by carthage1 pages

Superman (DCEU) vs. MCU Galactus

No Snydercut feats

Superman as of Justice League

who wins

Using the rule that no attribute can exceed on-screen feats, Superman wins.

Spoiler:
Galactus was no better than Thanos in terms of versatility. He lacked energy projection (aside from basic scanning) and had telekinesis, but showed no significant feats with it beyond levitating the Silver Surfer. His movements were incredibly slow, even by human standards. He couldn't fly or teleport, and he demonstrated poor awareness and intellect, failing to detect a trap or use his telekinesis to retrieve the baby.

If Superman can statue a bullet, then Galactus would appear as an even greater statue in comparison, giving Superman what amounts to an eternity to defeat him. At worst, Superman could simply BFR him into space.

Using the rule that every Carthage thread has Bane die in it, Bane dies.

Spoiler:
He dies, he dies, he dies he dies he diiiieeeessss!

I don't remember Superman 2025 having any super speed in combat. Lex easily kept up with him while conrolling Ultraman.

Originally posted by riv6672
Using the rule that every Carthage thread has Bane die in it, Bane dies.

Spoiler:
He dies, he dies, he dies he dies he diiiieeeessss!

No idea why I uncovered the spoiler.

I dont think spoilers are needed on a versus thread.

Originally posted by h1a8
and had telekinesis, but showed no significant feats with it beyond levitating the Silver Surfer.

He completely paralysed her.

Originally posted by Psychotron
I don't remember Superman 2025 having any super speed in combat. Lex easily kept up with him while conrolling Ultraman.
He didn't. Lex gave the commands either before Superman attacked or during an attack combination when Superman was incapacitated. Think about it, it's impossible to give a command mid-swing.

Plus this is Cavill Superman.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
I dont think spoilers are needed on a versus thread.

He completely paralysed her.

She was immobile without her board. All he did was lift her up. You could even say she was effectively paralyzed, as she had no means of escape without it.

Originally posted by h1a8
He didn't. Lex gave the commands either before Superman attacked or during an attack combination when Superman was incapacitated.

Yeah, that's impossible to do if Superman's moving at super speed.

Originally posted by h1a8
Plus this is Cavill Superman.

Right. My mistake. Superman should win based on feats, but Galactus should be far more powerful based on implied power.

Originally posted by h1a8
She was immobile without her board. All he did was lift her up. You could even say she was effectively paralyzed, as she had no means of escape without it.

You're saying it like that's something minor. As if he's just "lifting" and completely paralysing a normal human or something.

That's a Superman level character he did that to.

Originally posted by Psychotron

Right. My mistake. Superman should win based on feats, but Galactus should be far more powerful based on implied power.

Correct. Per film narrative nothing on Earth 828 (which aside from the fact they don't have mobile phones is clearly a much more advanced Earth) nothing to destroy Galactus.

Plus obviously implied more powerful than Silver Surfer. Comes back to the Odin issue. He had no feats but we knew he was far more powerful than Thor.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
You're saying it like that's something minor. As if he's just "lifting" and completely paralysing a normal human or something.

That's a Superman level character he did that to.

Correct. Per film narrative nothing on Earth 828 (which aside from the fact they don't have mobile phones is clearly a much more advanced Earth) nothing to destroy Galactus.

Plus obviously implied more powerful than Silver Surfer. Comes back to the Odin issue. He had no feats but we knew he was far more powerful than Thor.

So if someone incredibly strong - like Hulk - but unable to fly, were lifted off the ground with TK, wouldn't that be the equivalent of paralyzing them? Realistically, what could they even do in that state?

In most movies, the world's defenses are portrayed as far weaker than real-world militaries. That's why superpowered beings are often implied to only be stoppable by other superbeings - like Superman or Hulk. In that film, there wasn't even any indication that the world had nuclear weapons or a functioning police force.

In my opinion, that version of Surfer was terrible. She lacked versatility and had relatively weak durability. I wouldn't even consider calling her a Superman-tier character.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
No idea why I uncovered the spoiler.

^^^lol, made you look! 😄