Order of the Phoenix - OFFICIAL THREAD - ~*~SPOILERS~*~

she may be a cow but i don't think she wanted him dead
her explanation for doing it was that everyone else wanted to discredit harry but just twiddled there thumbs but she did something about it

The Dementor's Kiss has an INFINITELY worse result than death 😱 If I were in the HP universe, I would top myself right NOW in order to avoid receiving it. Yes, I was puzzled by the term "discrediting," Doesn't an attack mean an attempt on the soul? 😱

she knew he could defend himself and she knew he would defend himself and everyone else would see him as a silly little lier

Actually it was news to everyone at the hearing that Harry could produce a corporeal patronus. That charm is well beyond OWL standard.

i still dont think she wanted him worse than dead

Umbridge never came across as being sane.

you make a good point she was slightly deranged

maybe she sent the dementore cause he thought maybe voldy's followers can be around there?? i mean to protect harry
i have no idea what i'm talking about

I think that Padfoot's girl makes really good points, i think that they will both die, we always have to beware of loop holes in the prophecy, Dumbledore pissed me off alot in this book too, so did harry, but we're not going to get into that. Umbridge, she was evil, as evil as one of my teachers at school and that's saying alot, i think snape is probably afraid of voldemort, i don't think that he is still loyal to volde, i think if he was he wouldn't seem as evil as he is, it would be too obvious

Thank you Muse5! (cuz you said I make good points) I try to bring up interesting or thought provoking subjects so I'm glad I seem to have a friend here 🙂

... Well JK ows to the readers .... to publish it soon, cause ... itsd not good ... if wait a lot

what u ppl think????

I was just curious, Lily Evans how is the book coming along? I haven't gotten anything so I expect it's not finished yet since you promised you would send it to everyone. I hope it's going well and I hope nothing serious is delaying you (such as a cold or tragedy) No I'm not dramatic I'm concerned! 😛 well hope to get it soon I'm sure it'll be good. I always wanted to know about what happened with James(I love that name) and Lilly.

now today published out NOW i NEED IT

PrefectRonnykin: Do you mean that is published today???

of course she did. i think she said so herself.

Originally posted by angiethedragon
it probably won't come out for a while since JK is not only writing the books she is also writing the screenplays for the movies

writin' the screens`? i think steve cloves or how he was called ne1 from america) was writin them n he would wrote them further?

Originally posted by hhhhr
maybe she sent the dementore cause he thought maybe voldy's followers can be around there?? i mean to protect harry
i have no idea what i'm talking about

do you REALLY belive THAT woman tried to SAVE harrys life? why was she so ugly to him then?

Originally posted by Candy

do you REALLY belive THAT woman tried to SAVE harrys life? why was she so ugly to him then?

?

IMO not cool at all, but understandable.. and forgivable. having to cope with such terrible things at his age, who wouldnt be?

i think it would be a great challenge for Dan Radcliffe to do the 5th movie coz its hard to imagine him acting out that furiousness, he looks so sweet!

but i think "Goblet" is his last, so with Emma & Rupert coz they're growing up so fast. i wont be surprised if it'll be an entirely new cast for the 5th.