DUMBLEDORE [merged]

If someone could please tell me!!!!!!!! Thanks 😉 😱

Agreed

Dumbledore is not Harry's grandfather. The question was asked on jkrowling.com, and JK shot down this theory - "why would Harry have to stay with the Dursleys?", I think is what JK said.

MERGIED

GRandfather😑

No, he's not Harry's grandfather. That's just silly.

Hamm has a powerful voice though? Isn't that suitable?

I believe Gambon is doing a good job, but he doesn't have the flow that Harris did. Gambon is acting as dumbledore in front of a camera. Harris made the dumbledore whose essences was too large for the camera to do justice to.

I loved him in Camelot, Richard shall be missed, he IS Dumbledore.

Originally posted by tigress
I think the only person really who couldve followed Richard Harris would be sir Ian Mkellen as Dumbledore but he wasnt available, I didnt really warm to Gambon as Dumbledore but we'll see how he is in GOF, but its such a shame we lost Richard hes a legend

well I think McKellen looks way too different from Richard Harris.

He was a great actor - but aren't there like 4 or 5 other Harris threads? 😑

*bows head* Mr. Harris you will be dear to all of our hearts, we will miss you my good man. Thank you for the entertainment and the grace of your love.

I read something the other day on JK's website....about Dumbledore and his scar...........I wonder what happened..... it said he got a scar in London....and JK said she might tell us by book 7...that she was VERY fond of his scar.

Also she said that his patronus is a Phoenix and that he himself is very much like a Phoenix........... maybe Voldemort fears dumbledore b/c he cannot die????? Just a thought...........

hmm good point ...surly a character that old has died a number of time s..:lol

😂 True.................makes me wonder though.... he has a scar and Harry has a scar.....................very peculiar if you ask me! I know dozens of people have scars in real life...but this is a book..............

I am still hoping that D-dore ends up being Harry's grandfather!!!! After all it was up to him to give him a better home.....a "non-wizard" life.....

hmm it wud be cool but wot if dumbledore scar was also given to him by someone like voldie 😉

Merged.

I agree...

😄

I read a rumor that Dumbledore is Harry in the future. Its ridiculos of course and JK rebuffed it but if you think about it, its actually a really cool concept. Being there for your younger self, watching and remembering your younger self do things. Its crazy but then your older self had to be there for your younger self at one point and that means D dore is continuous...*gets headache* this whole time thing confuses the crap out of me. I tried to think in the third one about it but i ended up with a headache then too.

neat...