Why not use a time turner? *** spoiler***

Started by airangel4292 pages

Actually......if you all remember.....Luna, NEVILLE, Ginny, Hermy, Ron were all with Harry and all were eager to go and help Sirius...and it didn't matter HOW DANGEROUS it was................... the kids are braver than the adults... and why are they so scared? If there are muggles, why don't they just take a gun and shoot him! 🙂 I know....b/c maybe he will dissapperate...but still..you would think there are OTHER ways to take care of him..

OH AND I THINK FUDGE is under a spell...b/c he is AWFULLY under the impression that the Dark Lord doesn't exist...even when they saw....he was stumbling for words...didn't anyone else think this was weird? He couldn't deny it..b/c everyone else had seen what was going on and witnessed his being there.

I never thought about that... I mean, Malfoy was always hanging around the ministry and stuff... what if he put the Imperius Curse on Cornelius? I mean, wouldn't it have been easy? And note how fudge was out to get Dumbledore. What if the whole thing about believing that Dumbledore is plotting against him just a cover for Malfoy using Cornelius to stop Dumbledore and all. That's really deep! I never would have thought...

thanks....i have been thinking it since book 4 actually

I hope you don't mind me starting that thread...

no go ahead...i didn't mind 😄

this question may be off the subject a bit but when you were talking about jk and the mistakes she made in writing i had to say something that has bothered me. Jk is an awesome writer and i totally love her books however she does have some flaws. heres one that i just noticed. You can only see theastrals when you see someone die right. However at the end of harry potter 4 after harry has seen Cedric die he still cant see the theastrals. It even says on page 724 that the carrages still seemed horseless to Harry. Now sorry but that doesnt make sence to me
Does it have some sort of delayed reaction. Give me your thoughts

this has already been confirmed. u have 2 let the death sink in, meaning get used 2 it and move on.

what is meant of happened happen ... but mayb it happen for a good reason mayb 'the dead one' if he comes bak brings bak something of some signifagnce to help harry defeat the dark lord

he cant have a time turner. time turners r only issued by the ministry.

Spoiler:
i dont think the ministry will allow him 2 have 1 2 bring back what they think is a murder

yes and mayb they think he mite take it to far and try and save his parents which will screw it all up

The ony reason why they cant use them is cause then Voldemort wouldnt have come to the ministry and then we have alot of complications.

Voldemort would not have gone to the ministry and all and fought Dumbledore. then the ministry would have had to find out that he had risen the hard way so there are just to many things that would have to happen to use the time turner