Spidey vs Spider girl

Who do you think will win?I'll go with Spidey.

spidey girl has more powers than her father, but Spiderman has more fighting experience than her daughteher so spiderman

Ya,but younger people have better reflexes so there is a slight chance of spider girl winning.

spider-man has the strength, knowledge, and speed, so i'd think he'd win. spider girl inherited most of his qualities, but not his stregth. i haven't read the spider-girl comics, so i don't know much about the daughter.

since when does spiderman have a daughter??? ooo its probley just in the comics right?

I dont know I only read one comic with her I'm sure she is like Bat Girl.

Um...why would he fight his daughter? I mean I could see them not getting along, because they don't. But actually slugging it out? I don't know...

But if I must choose...I'd go with Spidey. No way he'd let his daughter kick his butt. Then she'd think she can get away with ever she wants. And that's not good disipline techniques 😆

Okay,pretend she comes home drunk.....No wait under control of an villian,and challenges her dad to a fight,and smacks him,now do you know what i mean?

But MJ wouldn't let her only daughter and her husband fight each other. And in the issue I saw, MJ is pretty much calling the shots over Peter.

But if they do I'd still go with Spidey...unless this villian that took her over, gave her like invincibility

No,pretend dock ock did it,and he did not know how to have invinsabilaty.

Then I'd still go with Spidey, but maybe I just don't like his daughter. She did seem very bratty in the comic

Spider man was aout to have a daughter, but it think Norma Osbourne food poisoned MAry JAne and the baby died. Spider Girl is actually taken place in the future in a possible reality where his daughther was still alive.

Oh, then okay....

So see!! Spidergirl can't kick Spidey's butt!!! Yay!

Oh?I am still going with Spidey!!! 🤘 😈

ok are you talking both in their prime or her timeline where peter's missing a leg or his time line where she isn't there?

but if both in their prime she would get beat so freakin fast she woudn't know what happened.spideys stronger spider girl is as fast as him but not faster so spidey would crush her.

i dont think they wud ever fite but spidy is the origional he has experience and i like him waayyyy better

Actually, they did face off in the Spider-Girl series...except it was an alternate reality Spidey who actually was a villain. He was in his prime, and although he was stronger, he still lost...although technically, he was still standing when the other heroes attacked and beat him for her.

Still, he was pretty much out though he was ready to keep fighting, Spidergirl would've taken him out pretty solidly. Her "sticking/repellant" powers made the difference, plus she was faster/more agile which even Spiderman admitted during the fight.

Though Spidey is a little stronger and more experienced, his daughter actually has more fighting spirit and seems to take a lot more punishment and keep on ticking against all odds...SO, I think Spidergirl would win in any case!

it's a tought call..........

Spiderman can take Scarlet Spider
Scarlet Spider beat Venom
Venom can take Spiderman
Spiderman "should" be able to take Spidey 2099*
Spidey 2099 went toe to toe with Venom

I guess it's up to the writer with such evenly matched opponents

*Spidersense beats enhanced vision in my book

Sorry, but Spider-Girl is awful.

She's just a "ooh lets take the original (spiderman) and make it a girl, but she has more powers, therefore shes better" - oh come on. That's bad storytelling at the expense of the original superhero (he has limits for good reasons people - storytelling). Spider-girl is another superhero added to an expanding list of "improved/better/overpowered" superheroes from this day and age.

And the fact that Spider-man was a villain when Spidergirl faced him means it has no bearring on what THE spider-man would do.

PS Spider-girl sucks. Sorry. Opinion.

Well, whether you like her or not, she is one of those "overpowered" rewrites of the original, and that's why she's able to beat the original Spidey, who I agree, is the better character by far!! Unfortunately, that doesn't change the fact that based on the proof so far, daughter beats father in a family squabble.