Petunia, A WITCH by secret?

Started by frootlooplucy2 pages

yeah, but i thought because V hated muggle borns he didnt consider them real witches or wizards... or something... and i always thought that petunia hated lil coz lily was a witch... but if PETUNIA was a witch... well that changes everything.

DOES make sense... it explains why she hates harry's magic - it reminds her again of what she can't have

it wud explain alot of things,it makes sense maybe thats why she hated lily and harry

yah...interesting but i think Petunia can be magical but her powers are not that seen or developed. Now I dont know what to think at all. There are just so many theories.

well dat is interestin

omg thats awsome!!! i do think there is something fishy going on with aunt petunia tho..i think she's bitter b/c maybe lilly got in and she didnt...maybe she went to hogwarts but failed cuz she (like neville) barely got in! maybe she got her wand snapped!! *triumphantly* i do think she IS a squib tho....: 😖hifty:

now i'm hearing a lot of rumours about some secrets of lilly potter that is going to be reaveled in the forthcoming harry potter books, and i've even heard one of my friend saying that even j k rowling has confirmed it. since then i've combing the internet for what it might be, and have come up with a pretty good number

PEOPLE PEOPLE! PERTUNIA ISN'T A WITCH BECAUSE SHE NEVER WENT OT HOGWATS OR HAD A MAGIC WAND! SHE AIN'T A SQUIB CAUSE THEY CAME FROM PURE BLOOD FAMILYS AND THE EVANS FAMILY ARE MUGGLES! I THINK THAT PETUNIA AND LILY WERE NICE UNTILL LILY GOT HER LETTER, MAB THEY FOUGHT OR PETUNIA GOT JEALUS, I THINK PETUNIA KNOW ABOUT THE MAGIC WORLD FROM HER SISTER AND DDS LETTER!

dang girl calm urself lol we're all just making up theories lol but i still think somethin happened btween lily and petunia!!!

In my opinion the "Petunia being a witch" thing makes sense because she's so jealous of Lily...but the thought of not having the love of her parents is also a reason for being jealous...No, I think she was jealous because Lily had so much she did not have: Lily was beautiful, Lily had friends (unlike Petunia...people who spend their whole life in spying out their boring neighbors do not have friends!!), Lily was clever and Lily was special. I think that are a lot of reasons for a person like Petunia (I repeat PETUNIA!!!) to be jealous.
Oh and that blood thing:
Hagrid says in the 2nd (when they're in Hagrid's house and Ron spits snails) that pure-bloods are wizards with NO muggle ancestors, wizards who NEVER got in touch with muggle blood. And half-bloods are all wizards who have muggle ancestors, even if they lived generations before them. And mud-bloods are people with ONLY muggle ancestors.

GOOD POINTS! 😄

Thanx ;-)