Invisible Woman's Forcefield versus Magneto's forcefield

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.



masterbruce
whose is more powerful?

ie. give examples of something that their forcefield protected against if possible.

Priest
Dident magneto's force feild was able to stop a attack from galactus?

bigbran
Originally posted by Priest
Dident magneto's force feild was able to stop a attack from galactus? Didn't Sue put a HOLE in Galactus?

Priest
Originally posted by bigbran
Didn't Sue put a HOLE in Galactus?
or exitar ur mean

bigbran
Originally posted by Priest
or exitar ur mean I was almost certain she did it to Galactus...

Priest
Originally posted by bigbran
I was almost certain she did it to Galactus...
never read the book my self, but im pretty sure it was exitar, plot device dervied ofcorce tho.

bigbran
Originally posted by Priest
never read the book my self, but im pretty sure it was exitar, plot device dervied ofcorce tho. I know she did it to Exitar, but I am almost positive that she did it to Galactus...

spidey-dude
G lanterns shield and magnetos are the strongest

spidey-dude
Originally posted by Priest
Dident magneto's force feild was able to stop a attack from galactus? when ?

Rutog98
Originally posted by bigbran
I was almost certain she did it to Galactus...

She did. She punched right through him.

Rutog98
Originally posted by spidey-dude
when ?

It was during Secret Wars. Galactus tossed a *VERY* low powered blast that didn't do much damage at all and Magneto's force-field withstood it. Its nothing much. To me, Cyclop's blast was stronger than what Galactus threw in that instance.

Stupid Rookie
Originally posted by spidey-dude
G lanterns shield and magnetos are the strongest

In regards to Magneto's being strongest, when G was attackig Thanos he said "never have I had to exert myself to penetrate a mere forcefield." or something like that. This leads me to believe his forcefield is not the strongest.

guy222
Originally posted by Priest
or exitar ur mean

Exitar has returned. Sorry Sue. Didn't the Brute smash that silly field? Taking Magneto

Acrosurge
Originally posted by Rutog98
It was during Secret Wars. Galactus tossed a *VERY* low powered blast that didn't do much damage at all and Magneto's force-field withstood it. Its nothing much. To me, Cyclop's blast was stronger than what Galactus threw in that instance. Are you talking about the first Secret Wars? Because that blast while it may have been low-powered compared to what Big G is capable, it still demolished Magneto's fortress. A good showing for Magneto, I think, but perhaps given too much credit since Galactus wasn't even trying to destroy him.

spidey-dude
Originally posted by Rutog98
It was during Secret Wars. Galactus tossed a *VERY* low powered blast that didn't do much damage at all and Magneto's force-field withstood it. Its nothing much. To me, Cyclop's blast was stronger than what Galactus threw in that instance. can you find out the exact issue #

Acrosurge
Originally posted by spidey-dude
can you find out the exact issue # It was Secret Wars #5, for what its worth.

jasofisc
both have extream feats so I don't know. the issue where thanos and Gal sorta fought was crap.

King Kandy
Originally posted by bigbran
I know she did it to Exitar, but I am almost positive that she did it to Galactus...
Yes, she did.

It was in the "Galactus the Devourer" min-series, which I might add is one of the weakest incarnations of Galactus there is.

LORDSIDIOUS01
Originally posted by guy222
Exitar has returned. Sorry Sue. Didn't the Brute smash that silly field? Taking Magneto


HAHAHAHAHA Eric Lensherr wins.

bigbran
Originally posted by King Kandy
Yes, she did.

It was in the "Galactus the Devourer" min-series, which I might add is one of the weakest incarnations of Galactus there is. Issue? I have it, but I only skimmed through it.

lucaschermont
For self defense,Magneto's are the best, for someone who cares about the whole world , Susan's force fields are better, magneto's force fields are useful for protecting himself, but they're no impenetabre, Shadowcat can go in his force field, and she can't go through susan's, for they have no molecular structure, susan's force fields can protect cities, not only herself, like magneto's, her force fields saved a city from a tsunami, and from a nuclear and a gamma blast, she already held the gladiator, the hulk and the thing at the same time,also pushed Hulk alway with one simple blast, Susan's force field's has already gone into the watcher force fields, and her force fields are in celestial level, she already blasted through a celestial armor, blasted exitar, and YES! she has already blasted through galactus!
and magneto's force fields in a wider range gets a lot weaker, like in the first issue of the x-men, where even cyclops was able to blast through it, Susan's force fields are way better than magneto's.

753
magnetos shields durabilty and his mental stamina in maintaining them are both better than sue's as they have a much better track record against external attacks, including times in which he covered huge areas with them. cyclops did not break through mags shields in the first issue of x-men, although there is some pis filled atempt at a retcon in which he hamers through a weakness line that never appeared again in the shield structure - karnak said the shield had no weaknesses at all. when did SC phase through them? they are not supposed to ahve any molecular structure either

Sue does not have celestial level shields, she only managed that because of her tie to hyperspace, not because of raw power.

psycho gundam
plus massive PIS

StiltmanFTW
The one that didn't get destroyed by repulsor rays.

Simbon
Sue once got her shields broken by Reed (and I'm not speaking metaphorically). It was when Overmind took over his mind.

psycho gundam
http://img96.imageshack.us/img96/2176/powers7.png

Konton
Originally posted by 753
magnetos shields durabilty and his mental stamina in maintaining them are both better than sue's as they have a much better track record against external attacks, including times in which he covered huge areas with them. cyclops did not break through mags shields in the first issue of x-men, although there is some pis filled atempt at a retcon in which he hamers through a weakness line that never appeared again in the shield structure - karnak said the shield had no weaknesses at all. when did SC phase through them? they are not supposed to ahve any molecular structure either

Sue does not have celestial level shields, she only managed that because of her tie to hyperspace, not because of raw power.

Eh, Sue recently held and maintained a forcefield around all of Atlantis in a meditative state for a very long extended period of time IIRC.

StiltmanFTW
Originally posted by psycho gundam
http://img96.imageshack.us/img96/2176/powers7.png

What actually happened in that scan? She immobilized him for one panel?

753
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
What actually happened in that scan? She immobilized him for one panel? I never got that either. people claimed he broke through her shields but I dont see it at all

OneDumbG0
^ Apocalypse simply misses. You see the blast go past her waist. But its very arguable that Invisible Woman is using her forcefield bubbles to force his arm out of position.

psycho gundam
no expression @ the last bit

753
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ Apocalypse simply misses. You see the blast go past her waist. But its very arguable that Invisible Woman is using her forcefield bubbles to force his arm out of position. that's what I figured. some people claim that because he first said that somethign was immobilizing him and then he managed to turn back and blast that meant he had broken her forcefields, but that's nonsense. she was clearly erecting a wall bewteen him and franklin not keeping him in one place with a skin-tight field. besides the shields arent broken and the blast doesnt hit her.

SamZED
Or maybe his aim just sucks.

753
like the rest of his shit. it's possible

Text-only Version: Click HERE to see this thread with all of the graphics, features, and links.