Star Trek reboot vs. Star Trek original

This is an entire movie type Galactus war with all of the Original characters including Original Spock alongside his Original universe. All the other parallel universe characters are aligned to stop them. Two movies versus many but I believe two movies with the newer anti Trekkie style more than makes up for it.

Each side has 1 week to prepare. Movies only for originals.

Who wins ?

Well ?

Nero drops red matter on all the enemy ships. New Trek wins.

Baiting aside, gonna have to be a bit more specific about what's included and what's not when it comes to the primary universe stuff. ermm

I mean, do they get Star Trek 6 and 7 too?

The original universe would include the Borg, Q Continuum, Jem' Hadar, Sisko, and Picard. They win. Effortlessly.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
The original universe would include the Borg, Q Continuum, Jem' Hadar, Sisko, and Picard. They win. Effortlessly.

if they are involved this is spite

Originally posted by Darth Martin
The original universe would include the Borg, Q Continuum, Jem' Hadar, Sisko, and Picard. They win. Effortlessly.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Baiting aside, gonna have to be a bit more specific about what's included and what's not when it comes to the primary universe stuff. ermm

I mean, do they get Star Trek 6 and 7 too?

I don't think even the Borg could stop a batch of Red Matter making their Cube implode.

And Nero's ship would do catastrophic damage.

Mmmm. The Borg should still be enough. Not to mention, I'm pretty sure The Enterprise E is much more potent than whatever version Pine's Kirk uses. The Sisko's Defiant also made an appearance in First Contact.

Not to mention, Data>Spock in pretty much every way martial arts prowess notwithstanding.

Originally posted by KingD19
I don't think even the Borg could stop a batch of Red Matter making their Cube implode.

And Nero's ship would do catastrophic damage.

The Red Matter is catastrophic but couldn't the Borg just adapt to it?

Wait, so the Federation fleet from first contact is in this too? and the scimitar?

This is spite.

Nero's ship MIGHT last a while, I guess. Everything else from that era gets murdered though.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
The Red Matter is catastrophic but couldn't the Borg just adapt to it?

Originally posted by Darth Martin
The Red Matter is catastrophic but couldn't the Borg just adapt to it?

How would they adapt to a void expanding inside their own Cube until it's completely imploded?

And Nero's ship took out like 10 ships in the beginning of the movie.

He just starts launching red matter at every ship. He played fast and loose with that stuff.

The only reason Nero was so impressive was because his technology dwarfed that of everyone in "reboot" timeline. He wasn't that smart of a strategist either.

It's one ship. The Borg have countless cubes. Starfleet in the original timeline is much more advanced.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Wait, so the Federation fleet from first contact is in this too? and the scimitar?

This is spite.

Nero's ship MIGHT last a while, I guess. Everything else from that era gets murdered though.

Originally posted by KingD19
How would they adapt to a void expanding inside their own Cube until it's completely imploded?

And Nero's ship took out like 10 ships in the beginning of the movie.

He just starts launching red matter at every ship. He played fast and loose with that stuff.

How would they get the red matter inside the cube?

Not to mention the fact that even firing red matter was a slow and delicate process. you'd have an enormous fleet of ships just as advanced as the narada (if not more advanced) firing at it from the start of the fight.

including a borg cube and a good 30 Starfleet ships (at least).

Originally posted by quanchi112
They didn't seem that formidable to me on screen. Send the super soldier in and he'd personally wreck them all.

Spoiler:
Khan

Originally posted by KingD19
And Nero's ship took out like 10 ships in the beginning of the movie.

He was pwning an inferior Starfleet in a less advanced timeline. I don't see them standing up to a well coordinated Starfleet assault like in First Contact with much more impressive weaponry than the Starfleet in the 2009 film showed.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
The only reason Nero was so impressive was because his technology dwarfed that of everyone in "reboot" timeline. He wasn't that smart of a strategist either.

It's one ship. The Borg have countless cubes. Starfleet in the original timeline is much more advanced.

He's from 130 years in the future regardless. And what's the difference between the reboot ships and the other ones?