Surfer solos. The guy is the fastest one on the feild, and has funky matter manipulation powers. Everyone here is top teir. apart from Surfer, who is at high herald level. As much as Supes and Capt. Marvel are my favourites here, they are not at that level.
i dont think Marvel can be affected my matter manipulation, Secondly, Lantern has the matter manipulation ability as well. Surfer may possibly be the fastest flyer if this were a race, but combat speed is another story.
Everyone on team one besides the Lantern have better combat speed, and the lantern has just as much power and versatility.
Hal versus the Surfer is pretty much a push - but Superman would have already stopped the Sentry, and Hal and Kal versus Norrin is a stomp in the Kryptonian and the Lantern's favor.
Thor, silver, gladiator, or sentry, I give a majority over superman, captain marvel is a different story though. I still give it to the marvel team and thats due to silver surfer and thor, to much raw power. They could conjour up things that would keep team one busy while the bricks lay waste to them. Gladiator speed>anyone on team 1 side.
I'm not too sure about your analogy of this fight. This is how I see it.
Glads vs Superman... Stalemate!
Gladiator is Superman, he can do anything that Superman can do including move objects that would fall apart under their own weight. The only thing that sets them apart is Gladiator's attitude. Despite popular belief Superman does not have the one thing that Thor does, and thats Mjolnir, it was Thors weapon that stopped Gladiator from winning a majority. Superman will not be given this luxury.
SS vs WW... SS Wins
I can't see how Wonder Woman wins here, SS has too many things to beat her with, and was able to resist Mephisto's will in hell. The Lasso could prove useless. But to make this even, if WW lassos SS she might/should/could win it all depends on if Norrin can actually fight the will of the lasso. On the flip side what would happen if SS trapped her in his board?
Thor vs CM... Thor wins.
I can see the Dread Destroyer punching CM into the pavement, and relentlessly giving him the beating that it used to give Thor. Thor just got a healthy upgrade. He lifted Asgard mystically, and how much does any want to guess Asgard weighs? A few hundred quintillion tons or more? CM isn't going to be hitting Thor with more than The Destroyer did, and Thor defeated it.
Sentry vs Hal...
This one is tricky I'm pulling for Sentry on this one because I don't see how Hal is blasting him with more power than Terrax did, and Sentry treated Terrax's blasts like they were rain drops. Could he rupture Hals light contructs? I'm pretty sure, that he has the power to do so.
6/10 to team 2. In fact, it depends of who fight who, but Marvel have a matter manipulator of great power, and on the other side, there is Superman, so...