The heralds win this. Surfer is the most powerful dude on the field, and the heralds are too versatile to loose to Superman, Martian Manhunter, and some ginger.
Could I be the only one that believes that Stardust would bake J'onn's cookies or what? Thor can handle Orion, and Norrin would be far faster than Superman in terms of traveling speed. Norrin's durability isn't bad either, being a herald of Galactus.
I can actually see any of the Marvel side cutting even with J'onn, or just plain overpowering him.
Let's just say that CIS was off in concerns to Norrin, and he was as blood thirsty as his Exiles counterpart. Do you believe that there is no form of energy capable of cutting Superman in half the way that to Gladiator was?
What about the idea that Norrin could drain Superman, which would effectively reduce him in power? Marvel has every right to stomp this one out.
I thought that all of those touched by Galactus had good resistance to TP assault? Stardust would bake J'onn. Stardust could open a portal to another dimension and send any one on team two into a dimension that houses beings that make Galactus, look insignificant. For example Asteroth was a cell of a much more powerful entity, and if left unchecked would have gained multi universal destructive powers. She would have fed on entire universes.
With CIS off Marvel has the potential to clean house here.
Energy draining isn't nearly as effective against Superman as most people think. In fact, he has his own draining abilities. He leeched/drained/absorbed energy from the Mageddon Anti-Sun that, really, was about to devastate the entire universe to the point that the Angels Of Heaven were preparing to build a new one.
Superman has flat out resisted energy draining before. And other times it's proven to be not all that effective, as he replenishes his power quite quickly.
Ruin had used solar energy drain, Kryptonite radiation, AND had taken the solar radiation he drained from Superman, converted it into red solar radiation, and blasted Superman with it. Still failed to put Superman down.