Who wins in an all out fight You do not have permission to vote on this poll.
Vadar Prime 3 18.75%
Luke Prime 13 81.25%
Total: 16 votes 100%
BrolyBlack Restricted Registered: May 2018Account Restricted
Luke Skywalker vs Darth Vadar
Luke Skywalker: The Mandelorian
__________________
04:10 PM
BrolyBlack Restricted Registered: May 2018Account Restricted
__________________
04:12 PM
WolvesofBabylon Welcome to the machine Registered: Nov 2017
Re: Luke Skywalker vs Darth Vadar
quote: (post ) Originally posted by BrolyBlack Luke Skywalker: The Mandelorian
12:14 AM
xPRIMEx Senior Member Registered: Apr 2018
Luke should be better by 9 ABY. He was already stated to be Vader’s equal as of rotj
12:49 AM
BrolyBlack Restricted Registered: May 2018Account Restricted
To be fair badas could have done the same thing.
__________________
02:03 AM
juggernaut74 Bigsexy Registered: Oct 2004
I would say Vader because of the fact he was working in tighter quarters I think.
__________________
02:38 AM
Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed Registered: May 2012
Luke's showing is vastly more impressive from a feats standpoint due to what he was fighting.
__________________
06:02 AM
BrolyBlack Restricted Registered: May 2018Account Restricted
I think Like feat was more impressive but I don’t doubt Vader could easily accomplish the same feat.
__________________
08:12 AM
Darth Thor Senior Member Registered: Apr 2008
quote: (post ) Originally posted by xPRIMEx Luke should be better by 9 ABY. He was already stated to be Vader’s equal as of rotj
08:17 AM
Galan007 |Quantum Observer| Registered: Jul 2006
If we're talking about which showing was superior in terms of feats, then Luke's by far. Vader killed ~12 fodder Rebel troops in the corridor. Luke casually raped something like 30 Dark Troopers(which are presumably among the most advanced/elite droids ever constructed.)
__________________
04:28 PM
Superdad76 dad Registered: Dec 2020
it should be luke but darth could get stronger with better technology
__________________
06:55 PM
Psychotron Senior Member Registered: Jun 2011
Luke. He was already Vader's equal in ROTJ. Now he's got 5 years of more experience and growth.
08:14 PM
xPRIMEx Senior Member Registered: Apr 2018
As for which scene was better: I’m a huge Vader fan and as much as I loved his hallway scene in Rogue One, I have to say that Luke’s scene in Mandalorian was even better. The build up, the music, the dark troopers, everything was amazing.
09:15 PM
BrolyBlack Restricted Registered: May 2018Account Restricted
^ __________________
10:13 PM
Scizard Senior Member Registered: Dec 2019
Thought Luke's hallway scene was kinda meh compared to Vader's/Mauls ngl, Luke is probably the superior combatant by 9ABY though.
10:22 PM
ares834 Senior Member Registered: Apr 2009
It was way cooler than Maul’s. Vader’s was more interesting though.
12:44 AM
Scizard Senior Member Registered: Dec 2019
I dunno man, the choregraphy just felt very meh to me, didn't have that little effort vibes all the way through like Vader/Maul did.
01:56 AM
Scizard Senior Member Registered: Dec 2019
I'm guessing we're gonna be getting more hallway scenes now though lol. It'll be fun to rank them all as time goes on, for now:
01:56 AM
Zenwolf Senior Member Registered: Dec 2013
Maul's was kinda dumb honestly in the way it played out.
__________________ "Commence primary ignition."
02:15 AM
Psychotron Senior Member Registered: Jun 2011
Luke's is more badass because fought tougher opponents and it had better build up.
06:17 AM
All times are UTC. The time now is 06:05 PM.
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threadsmay not post repliesmay not post attachmentsmay not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF vB code is ON Smilies are ON [IMG] code is ON
Text-only version
Dec 19th, 2020 04:10 PM
