Thanos vs All Star Superman

Started by TricksterPriest5 pages

😆 Really? Like where? I've never seen a single lemon fic with Thanos in it.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
You have points of view that I consider reasonable as well. But it is apparent to me that you are perfectly willing to assume anything favorable to your position or your character, even though an equally or more plausible explanation exists. And the only leap of logic I made in T&A thread was that they a part of cosmic consonance like Galactus, considering their origins, their so-called roles as Proemiel Elders and their status as the only 3 Proemiel Elders left. I don't consider that hyperbole in the least. I made an analogy and projected similarities to make a point. Are you referring to some other "hyperbole," I made in that thread? Just because you don't believe Spectre to be beatable, doesn't change the fact that Spectre has been pantsed, manipulated, made mistakes, and forced to steal magic to win. And just because you are so quickly and perfectly willing to assume that all those are PIS-driven, doesn't mean that others are. It's only logical that most people on these forums start bringing him down a notch.

I don't have my comics in my NYC apartment. I leave em in my parent's house, there are just too many. But when they first go to and leave from Apokolips, they do have motherboxes with them. They make specific references to them. Your only rationalization that he did it himself is that they didn't depict him clicking one on. That is indeed, your sole reasoning for it. It is completely circumstantial. Considering they had motherboxes with them on their rescue mission and they are never depicted on panel to be holding them, it makes the later scene consistent with the artist's choice of depiction. Indeed, Turner was too lazy to even show what his interpretation of a motherbox was. That combined with Superman never hinting, thinking or showing such an ability beforehand and since then, makes your reasoning facially weak. Indeed, some of your contemporaries are not willing to go so far and assume as much as you do, batdude123, for instance. My reasoning is not just rational. It is obvious.

And you still didn't answer my question. What feat of Superman's do you think Superman-haters consider to be PIS? In my opinion, he's done nothing that you couldn't find another character doing or surpassing.

However, the only person ever mentioning a boomtube or a motherbox prior to leaving is Barda, and her only mentioning of it was her reiterating the fact she is indeed the one with the motherbox as to why she should be allowed to go. The only other person we see doing anything with Barda's tech other than Barda, is Batman asking to borrow armor.

I dunno, let me grab a few instances for example;

Originally posted by llagrok
Didn't Darkseid lose to Superman? Was the PIS?

Haven't read the fight myself, can't say.


Even though he's done so, three times in the past few years?

This one is from Superman heat visioning Despero.

Originally posted by Estacado
Wait isn't that from the same series where Batman beat Solomon Grundy in a h2h fight?
Stop using PIS as evidence!!!!!

How about regarding his willing off magic and magic effects?

Originally posted by Milkie
You're trying to make it out like he can fight off magic. Most of his magic showings are PIS. DC doesn't want their boy scout to lose all the time. Funny how magic works on other magical characters but not Superman 🙄

This is just from a minute or two of searching. I could easily go on.
Superman was voted to be the most hated character on the forum a handful of months ago, so it's easy to see why this takes place.

Superman shouldnt have any damn magic resistance! Ugh I cant stand what they do with him.

Originally posted by TricksterPriest
😆 Really? Like where? I've never seen a single lemon fic with Thanos in it.

Shazam !

http://www.superstories.net/story/character/Thanos.html

Originally posted by Juntai
However, the only person ever mentioning a boomtube or a motherbox prior to leaving is Barda, and her only mentioning of it was her reiterating the fact she is indeed the one with the motherbox as to why she should be allowed to go. The only other person we see doing anything with Barda's tech other than Barda, is Batman asking to borrow armor.
Batman specifically stated that a motherbox was protecting him when Darkseid was pounding on him. Go to the panel where they open a boom-tube and they carry off Kara. Do we see anybody taking out a motherbox or saying anything to a motherbox or even the motherbox being depicted at all? No. So it's consistent later on when a boom-tube opens but we don't actually see a mortherbox. And thanks for pointing this out: The fact that Barda forced Superman to take her along because he needed the motherbox to get to Apokolips is truly evidence that Superman couldn't make a boom-tube and needed one later on. I forgot about that little blackmailing that Barda pulled. Thanks for strengthening my argument.
Originally posted by Juntai
I dunno, let me grab a few instances for example;

Even though he's done so, three times in the past few years?

This one is from Superman heat visioning Despero.

How about regarding his willing off magic and magic effects?

This is just from a minute or two of searching. I could easily go on.
Superman was voted to be the most hated character on the forum a handful of months ago, so it's easy to see why this takes place.

Most people who hate the facts that Superman has beaten Darkseid and Despero are Darkseid and Despero fans. I never took issue with them. Captain America has willed off the effects of magic and goddesses. Superman doing so is no surprise to me. Such instances do not have to be written off to explain their occurrences. There is almost always a pretty simple and valid explanation for it. I do however, take issue with choosing the far-fetched conclusions when an easier solution is just as capable of explaining the incredulity of the scene.

Show me anything that says Captain America can take Dr. Strange

Are you asking me? He hasn't resisted Dr. Strange, not to my knowledge. However, he has fought off the magic from the Enchantress in 'Secret Wars.' I'm not sure I understand the point of your question.

Originally posted by roughrider
Maybe DC isn't liking what they see in having All-Star versions. Batman is certainly an embarrassment.
A/S Supes is an excellent selling book for DC, so my guess is that they are liking it quite a bit. 🙂

And A/S Batman is a pretty good book, and now that it's back on track, it won't be such an embarrassment.

Originally posted by Big Sexy
( event though it seems that the ultimates and All Star Batman are in a contest to see who can delay their book the longest).
Meh,

A/S Batman should take that trophy easy. 😂

Originally posted by Galan007
A/S Supes is an excellent selling book for DC, so my guess is that they are liking it quite a bit. 🙂

And A/S Batman is a pretty good book, and now that it's back on track, it won't be such an embarrassment. Meh,

A/S Batman should take that trophy easy. 😂

Is ASBatman an amped up version of Batman?

Thanos ftw.

Originally posted by masterbruce
Is ASBatman an amped up version of Batman?
Not really,

But IMO it's a pretty good read, (not quite as good as A/S Superman though). 😂

Originally posted by Galan007
Not really,

But IMO it's a pretty good read, (not quite as good as A/S Superman though). 😂

ah ok...so what's the difference between AS Batman and regular Batman, if any?

Originally posted by masterbruce
ah ok...so what's the difference between AS Batman and regular Batman, if any?
Not a whole lot.

A/S Batman is a little more grungy, (eg. Not afraid to slap up Alfred) 😂

But I haven't noticed too much more a a difference besides that.

Originally posted by Galan007
Not a whole lot.

A/S Batman is a little more grungy, (eg. Not afraid to slap up Alfred) 😂

But I haven't noticed too much more a a difference besides that.

slap Alfred...wtf?

Originally posted by masterbruce
slap Alfred...wtf?
Yeah, Bats about kicked his ass for giving Robin a cheeseburger... 😆

Originally posted by Galan007
Yeah, Bats about kicked his ass for giving Robin a cheeseburger... 😆

😆 😱 😂 😆 friggin awesome

Originally posted by masterbruce
😆 😱 😂 😆 friggin awesome