You see it isn't just the hammer vs the rings though it's two Superman level characters with Hammers against the rings.
Thor has stood in the middle of the sun before with the fire swirling around him with no harm and he didn't evne need shielding.
I think that is what I'm getting at. You have two Superman level strength characters and characters with Great durability on top of the Hammers that is hard combination to beat if you think about.
Thile overall the rings are better than the hammers that doesn't equate to a win here.
eh, I would rather take Hal with a GL ring over Superman with a GL ring. Seriously. The rings auto defenses give them what Superman's natural defenses give them
Think of it this way (very dumbed down version). You have Captain America with his super shield. Then you have Tony Stark with his Ironman suit. Now Captain America's human stats>>>Tony's and his shield is stronger than Tony's. BUT Tony's suit gives his soooo much more versatility that we all know Ironman should win.
Thor's physical stats>>>Hal/Kyles. The hammer may "hit" harder. But the rings give them more power than the what thor has
I nuderstand what your saying but that is a very bad comparison because all Cap has is his normal physcal advantages Thor and BRB already are on the lines of Hal and Kyle without having to amp themselves up because with Amping Kyle and Hal can match Thor and BRB but Thor adn BRB don't have to.
On the other hand though Thor and BRB can use all their powers without having to worry about amping themselves up see what I'm saying. It's one less thing they have to worry about which will make a big differnce in this fight. Because if BRB and Thor are draining Hal and Kyle while swinging at them. Well now along with having to amp themsleves they have to to mange to keep their powers from being drained. It's like an endurance test. All of which is drainign and as we know GLs that use to much power do get weaker with use.
Plus Hal and Kyle have been shown that they can only amp themselves so much becuase none of them truely are an all out match physcially for Supes. You add i nthe fact that each one of Thor's and BRB's attacks will be hitting with more force then Superman's attacks that is hard for willpower based people to stand up to.
Plus magic is always a kind of iffy spot for a GL to begin with that The Asgardains attacks may even be more efftive then normal.