Movie novelistion isn't the best source to go with. It's essentially Stover's take on a character he didn't create. Also, it doesn't make any sense in light of the evidence. But you're Lightsnake; defender of the hyperbolic claim.
What other sources? Specifically?
O rly? This would be a first.
You miss the point- Yoda is supposively according to you the best jedi of all time, yet he can't whack Dooku, his own apprentice, inside of a minute. Sucks to be him.
Yes, the same guy who held a jedi master captive with relative ease. Nadd's puppet.
I've never been a fanboy, Lightsnake, but you have been. You fit into every possible Fanboy Commandment, and then some. You're the guy who argues "X loses because he didn't impress me".
Oh, give me a break! Your arugment is it isn't valid because it's 'the author's take?' Welcome to the writing world! It's still the novelization, it's in the EU and uncontradicted. So...Ackbar isn't a great tactician because? Guess what, Janus, the source is canon in the EU, you are not.
And isn't SWcomics down? And Torr Snappit, fought with a staff, later substantiated in the Tales of the Jedi. Power of the Jedi also backs Yoda, up, as does Courtship of PRincess Leia, The Visual Dictionary, Insider..
And gee, Dooku is only Yoda's former padawan, practically his SON and Yoda is aiming not to kill him. Dooku runs and realizes Yoda's the far better. Not up for debate who the stronger is.
You're claiming Freedon Nadd, in light of all evidence can stand against two of the strongest Jedi who've ever lived. Like I said, you're either being facetious or...
True or False: Ommin was a powerless blob on the floor after Ulic demolished his life support?
Oh, please, I mentioned that 'didn't impress me bit' unconnected to my main argument when we were discussing the thing.
And yeah, fanboy commandments. That's great. Never minding how I could easily apply the reverse to you here...what's your argument, 'his dark side presence' lingered on? Couldn't have ANYTHING to do with him stashing a shipload of Naga's Sith items on Onderan? Once more, this is the guy killed in a native uprising. Come on, what are these excellent fanboy commandments? 'Argues because he believes so and so is better?' Yep, to you that seems to be it
__________________ Thanks to Venificus:
Last edited by Lightsnake on May 5th, 2006 at 10:53 PM
May 5th, 2006 10:44 PM
