Pirates of the Carribean mistakes

Started by Phoenix11 pages

Pirates of the Carribean mistakes

Quite an intriguing read....

http://www.moviemistakes.com/film.php?filmid=3372

how do people NOTICE these things?!?!? I spent a good part of the movie staring dreamily at Johnny Depp!

:laugh; some are really good...especially the factual errors. That one with the boat on the bottom of the see is ebvious..but i let it go because the movie is funny and not made strictly to teh details.

the black pearl shouldn't even move with those whole in sails...but the whole enhace the atmosphere..so there you go

god lol lots of mistakes! but who cares? its still a great film!!!

wrong bout the bout thingy under water

"Captain Norrington is "promoted" to Commodore. However, commodore was not a rank in the British navy, but a posting. A post captain could be appointed commodore (meaning he commanded more than one vessel) for a specific task, but when that task was completed, he became a post captain again. A promotion would have made Norrington an admiral."

That is STAGGERINGLY petty! You can't promote someone Admiral unless there is a vacancy and Commodore WAS recognised as a seperate rank, temporary or otherwise. They could just fudge it by saying he had a permanent detached command of his own.

You should correct that mistake Ush.

I was in this site and discovered that the longer the movies the more mistakes.. in most of the movies around the same length there were around 100 mistakes.. therefore POTC styll rocks!!!and did good considering he length

aye! but they missed one VERY IMPORTANT AND ANNOYING MISTAKE!!!! that necklace chain must be magical!!! they keep ripping it off and putting it back on! ever since elizabeth first met will! she ripped it off his neck, then put it back on with no trouble, and ripped it off, and put it back on....

Originally posted by CapinJacksparow
aye! but they missed one VERY IMPORTANT AND ANNOYING MISTAKE!!!! that necklace chain must be magical!!! they keep ripping it off and putting it back on! ever since elizabeth first met will! she ripped it off his neck, then put it back on with no trouble, and ripped it off, and put it back on....

this was mentioned a lot actually, but in the 'corrections' part. it was mentioned that theyre are necklaces that are DESIGNED to snap off, eg for if you get it caught on something, then it wont strangle you. also, old fashioned chains for necklaces were made so you could fasten it ANYWHERE on the chain, so they just made one type of chain, instead of faffing about making ones for wide necks and narrow necks

Funny that same thing was noticed in the Fellowship of the rings, frodo kept losing the chain with the ring.
It must be a standard movie prop where chains just come off with a little tug

😂 its good to see moviemistakes is still maintaining their 'magnifying glass investigation' mode................keep up the good work guys...it gives us more reasons to watch our fave movies over and over

ok ive really got a question about the movie because there is a part that i didnt understand. i dont know how to do that thing to make it all black unless you highlight it so i'll just give this warning

IM PUTTING SPOILERS BELOW!!!!!!! DONT READ IF YOU DONT WANT TO SEE SPOPILERS!!!!!!!

ok in the end scene where jack is saying you will remember today as the day you almost caught....and then he falls into the water, well when he looks up from the water there is a ship that has white sails. then when he gets on the ship it is the pearl like it should be with black sails. did i just miss something because i dont get it. i must be just making a stupid mistake because they didnt mention it on that webpage of POTC mistakes.

a little help would be greatly appriciated

thanks

aye! thank you for tellin me the truth on the necklace thing! i thought i was insane and the only one who noticed the mistake but it was actually ment to be! i'm happy now....
but to answer the question about the white sails. in the time that jack's tortuga crew took the ship and brought it to port royal, they got it fixed. as you remember it was in a raging battle against the interceptor. and of course, it was damaged. so they fixed it up for jack, and added new sails. they where white because it's kinda hard to find black sails in the caribbean. hope that answers it for ye.

Originally posted by Kes
You should correct that mistake Ush.

I would, but that COULD be seen as even MORE petty!

Originally posted by Ushgarak
I would, but that COULD be seen as even MORE petty!

😂

Well if a mistake is not a mistake eit should be corrected,right?! 🙂

Yeah... but frankly, I hate that site anyway, it's always full of rubbish.

Well they do have a way to correct the ones that are wrong.
I like it. I love looking for mistakes.

Well, maybe...

...I have a question...:
When Barbosa and the crew of the Pearl are making Elizabeth and Jack walk the blank, Barbosa demands the dress he gave Elizabeth back. She acquiesces, saying "It goes with your black heart." BUT THE DRESS IS A MAROON/PURPLE, not black at all! What gives???