I was also reading these mistakes and they really seem to be picking at little things but, some of it is interesting.
One that stood out was a fact towards the bottom iof page one that said "if sparrow was cursed how could he get drunk on the island?". I mean this is something I picked up on the first time I saw the movie but, jack lift's four coins from the chest and only puts three back...so he is only cursed from the moment he keeps the fourth coin (under his sleeve it looks like) until the point he cuts himself and throws the coin back to will to lift the curse.
I dunno i just thought that one was really stupid because if you followed along you would have known jack was only cursed for a brief time at the end of the film.
Hey, I'm new here, but I've read this whole topic, and I just have a question, hopefully someone will have the answer...
In the last bit of the movie when Sparrow, Barbossa, Turner, and Swann are in the cave place, why does Jack slice his own hand before he throws the coin to Will? I've thought of many different reasons, but none of them seem quite right... So if someone has the answer, or just their opinion of it, I would be VERY grateful if you could post it here!
Thanks!