there are some good points here but i would have to say ARAGORN have u seen how many orcs he has killed like these things are like 7ft tall and in LOTR ROTK aragorn took on a TROLL a tall big TROLL yeah he didnt kill it but HE DIDNT GET KILLED HIMSELF AND jack would NOT use his gun because it only has one bullet and he is saving that bullet for barbosa so I SAY ARAGORN ( and he is not ****ing arogant )
Originally posted by StriderknightUm,last time I cheacked all it took to kill somone was the pull of a trigger.
((God people,if you think Jack didn't reload his pistol after he shot Barbosa,you all need to pick up a book or two and read about Pirates))
Didnt Jack throw the gun away after shooting Barbossa.
I think it's funny how you all think you know exactly what each of them would do. Have you even thought about the conscience of each character?? Aragorn's a better fighter, but he's also a man...a Dunedain ranger. So he's got conscience enough to not just kill every thing that crosses his path.
Jack Sparrow wouldn't do that either. I don't even understand why this thread exists when both the characters are too complicated for an exact answer. Isn't it obvious that people will say Aragorn will win if their fave movie is LOTR, and Jack will win if they prefer POTC? It's a recipe for disaster!
--Liv
ok sweetie erm i kno they'd never fite...i mean they'r ein different worlds!!! but the thing is that if it came down to fighting, who would win? basically, who has the most skill in battle? and i fpeople wanna respond w/their favorite character then they can. personally i like jack better.. but aragorn would win.
I know this is a new offer of an opinion but i think that JOHNNY DEPP could kick VIGO MORRISON's ass. Vigo and Johnny are very alike but in the case of their characters i don't think Aragorn would go to the Carribbean and i highly doubt that Jack would ever take the time to get up and go to Middle Earth. By the way did you know that Jack's jacket is going up for auction?
Originally posted by billyboyd4ever
ok sweetie erm i kno they'd never fite...i mean they'r ein different worlds!!! but the thing is that if it came down to fighting, who would win? basically, who has the most skill in battle? and i fpeople wanna respond w/their favorite character then they can. personally i like jack better.. but aragorn would win.
ok well if you put it that way i think nobody would win, it would be an epic battle and they would have to call in troops, Jack would keep re-loading his gun and fight with his sword and Aragorn would fight with bows and arrows and sword. Then maybe we could release some doves and Aragorn would regain his peaceful side and go back to his throne and Jack would put on some more eye make up (khol) and go back to drinking and they would continue over seas letters. All's well that ends well.
lol jack would win coz aragon would be all 'im gonna kil you' then jack does some kewl moves n they have a sword fight, then they get too tired coz they been fighting for ages... n jack goes 'lets have sumat to drink' n they have a few and aragon is drunk then jack shoots him with his last shot! woohoo JACK WON!! 😄